Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by crispinb on Sunday May 05, 2019 @09:27PM
(#19836182)
Looks nice. I've been a 1password user for some years, but the lack of a proper linux client is a pest. Bitwarden seems like it would be worth a try.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by makeramen on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:19AM
(#19837044)
I too tried to like Bitwarden but have been disappointed. In the meantime I've made a basic linux CLI for read-only access, seems to be sufficient for the time being: https://github.com/vinc3m1/1pa
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by crispinb on Monday May 06, 2019 @02:26AM
(#19837257)
Nice! I don't have an opvault file right now as I use AgileBits' sync service, but I'll create one next time I'm in windows and give this a try.
(An aside: every time someone points out a golang repo I'm impressed by the code readability, given I'm only passingly familiar with the language)
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by crispinb on Sunday May 05, 2019 @10:04PM
(#19836306)
Hmm. Not a great start - 'select all' on the linux client selects all the page text, rather than the items, so there's no way to bulk edit. Doesn't engender much confidence.
[Edit: OK it turns out to be an electron app, and a barely functional one at that]
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by dpark on Monday May 06, 2019 @09:22AM
(#19839139)
Out of curiosity, why would you ever want to select all in your password manager?
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by crispinb on Monday May 06, 2019 @06:58PM
(#19844782)
In this particular case it's because I wanted to move all the items from a single imported 1Password vault (I have a few for different purposes) into a Bitwarden folder.
But more generally, when trying new software I tend to exercise its functionality as a first QA pass. There's a 'select all' entry in the Edit menu, and a keyboard shortcut, so it seems reasonable to try it. The failure isn't in itself a show stopper, but it's a mark against the app for me.
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by dpark on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:31PM
(#19844986)
Folder organization makes sense. My guess is this shows up as a shortcut “for free” as a result of it being electron based. I think the “native” client is the newest client Bitwarden offers and probably hasn’t gotten as much polish yet.
Re:New, portable, open source password manager for Windows
by crispinb on Monday May 06, 2019 @07:55PM
(#19845116)
Yes agree on the shortcut 'for free' aspect, but I'd consider expunging unused default menu items as part of a very basic pre-release checklist, rather than 'polish'. I don't share the frequently-expressed antipathy to electron apps, but many are quite shoddy, which only adds to their poor reputation. I've seen commercial apps which (for example) replace their whole window contents with a dragged image.
I'll keep an eye on Bitwarden - I like the overall shape of the project, but it's not ready for me yet (had some problems with the firefox extension also).