> but the mechanism behind this is entirely hand-waving.
The objective of this paper was not to specify, or even attempt to specify, the mechanism.
> The paper's use of machine learning seems entirely pointless, basically drawing the obvious line between the two sets of points.
Yeah, that is pretty much the entire objective of SVMs.
Which is hard to do by hand in many dimensions but almost trivial in 2. I haven't read the paper but maybe the OP is complaining about something like that?
Yeah, I was expecting to see flow cytometric cell sorting (1) for monocytes on CD14 and CD64 (2), which I would believe to be monocytes.
The "sample preparation" procedure they describe (3) is ... somewhat lacking in specificity. They pelletized the sample three times. I'm not even sure those cells are intact, and, mechanistically, the sample no doubts includes granulocytes, lymphocytes, and monos, so who knows what's going on there.
(1) https://www.labome.com/method/Flow-Cytometry-and-Cell-Sortin...
(2) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9844593
(3) https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2019/04/25/190127411...
If I'm reading the paper correctly, the samples were peripheral blood mononuclear cells (i.e. lots of different cell types) in their own plasma. It would be nice to have samples that weren't so heterogeneous, since it's unclear what type of cell is causing the effect, or if it is something in the plasma.
It would be nice if the paper gave the actual measured resistances, rather than % deviation from normalized impedance which is an unusual unit. The paper's use of machine learning seems entirely pointless, basically drawing the obvious line between the two sets of points.
The discussion section didn't seem to have anything concrete. It reminded me of a patent application where you try to list everything that might possibly turn out to be vaguely related.
I apologize for the negativity; the paper's result is very exciting so I hope it pans out, but I found the paper itself disappointing.