News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by rayiner on Saturday May 04, 2019 @02:58PM (#19828475)
This article wildly misrepresents Hungary’s new overtime law. The article makes it seem like employers can demand workers to work 400 hours of overtime and not pay them until 3 years later. The fact that it talks about the “perception” of the law rather than the actual legal provisions is telling. Here is what the law does: https://www.twobirds.com/en/news/articles/2019/hungary/new-c....

The law primarily regulates the terms of collective bargaining agreements. Most EU countries provide for such agreements to include a maximum amount of overtime for scheduled hourly workers. Some countries, like the US and Netherlands, don’t specify any maximum. The new Hungary law raises the overtime limit from 250 hours per year to 400. (France, for example, is 220. Norway is up to 400 by individual agreement. In California, there is no annual limit, but workers can’t be disciplined for not working more than 72 hours per week. The Netherlands has no annual limit, but a limit of 60 hours per week. In the new Hungary law, the maximum per week is 48.)

The three years is not how long employers have to pay for the extra hours, but refers to the “reference period” in the collective bargaining agreement over which what counts as overtime is calculated. People must still be paid their hourly rate for those overtime hours. A reference period in excess of court months, moreover, can only be set forth in a collective bargaining agreement.

Calling raising the limit on maximum overtime a “slave law” is propaganda, pure and simple. (Unless you subscribe to the notion that working for someone who privately owns the means of production is “wage slavery” but if that’s the case you should flag that premise to avoid misleading the reader.)

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by Luc on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:27PM (#19828664)
So an employer could make someone work 400 hours of overtime for a couple of years, yet never pay them the overtime rate. They could do this by reducing the employee's hours in the third year, so that averaged over 3 years no overtime was due.

That sounds like a great deal... for the employer.

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by metafex on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:50PM (#19828849)
Yes, the employers can and will try to pay out the overtime only after that time. And some are already trying to do just that. There have been large protests which the state media doesn't even cover at all and honestly, calling this propaganda is quite dishonest. Also workers are being "convinced" to sign agreements because otherwise they are out of a job.

Source: Austrian with Hungarian partner, and with friends in Hungary.

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by rayiner on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:56PM (#19828901)
Under the law, overtime hours may not be counted as overtime until a calculation is done over the full reference period. But the article makes it seem like employers can get away with not paying the base wage for those extra hours until three years later. That is false.

The three year reference period also can only be used in a collective bargaining agreement. (Otherwise it’s four months.) So you’re not talking about an individual negotiating with the company under threat of losing her job. It’s the union negotiating with the employer. You’re saying even that isn’t enough—it’s slavery unless the law prevents the union from negotiating a higher reference period. That’s propaganda.

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by metafex on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:10PM (#19829010)
Not all workers have a union. And the current trend in Hungary is to take away more and more workers rights. A law is quite toothless if it's not implemented that way.

Example for workers rights: Currently unemployed people get benefits for some time and after that the state will employ them (see közmunka) for less than minimum wage. In practice, what happens is that some companies previously employed workers with minimum wage, let them go and re-employed them for a lower wage via the state. This in turn creates an incentive to keep those workers in this perpetual state, because it's less desirable to employ them directly. (And no, they don't get any more money from the state or anything to match the loss of wage)

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by rayiner on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:19PM (#19829085)
> Not all workers have a union.

The three year reference period doesn’t apply to those workers. If there is no union, there is no collective bargaining agreement, and without a collective bargaining agreement the maximum reference period under the law is 4 months (similar to the rest of Europe). As to hours, the new Hungary law is not crazy out of line with that of other countries, especially the more market-oriented/capitalist European countries. The Netherlands and Denmark have no annual overtime limit. In the Netherlands you can be asked to work up to 60 hours per week. In Denmark it’s 48 hours. Norway has a limit of 400 hours by agreement. The new Hungary law works out to being the same as Norway, similar to Denmark, and less than the Netherlands. Austria has an extremely low limit (60 hours). Maybe that’s a good idea and maybe it’s not. But people in Norway aren’t “slaves.” Calling more liberalized, but still within the mainstream, labor regulations “slavery” is propaganda. And it’s propaganda to try and make readers think workers are being told to work for free.

Re:Businesses are scrambling for workers in Hungary by zefool on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:17PM (#19829064)
> In California, there is no annual limit, but workers can’t be disciplined for not working more than 72 hours per week.

So in California, it's not illegal to discipline your employees for working a mere 70 hours per week?