If I am not the first one to point out your failure of understanding the Principle of Charity, do us all a favor and focus on that before continuing discussion with others online.
The point at which I start to think it might be being misused is when it is not being used to look for a more gentle version of what could be unintentional ambiguity, but rather is being used to change meaning from the literal sense of a sentence to something in favor of a current position in a discussion, as this invites people to try and have their cake and eat it.
If it makes it easier for you, forget the "nobody" paragraph or substitute for "a very tiny minority compared to the total population of people/companies that make software for a living".
With this in mind, think of how many companies would actually benefit from focusing on "data used by the software is local-first" vs "the software should get things done faster/help the user make more money/help the user get laid"?
If you actually argue that companies in fact would benefit from focusing on this but can not due to some technical limitation, then we would have a legitimate point of discussion. But it seems you can't, so all I am getting from you is this insipid argument over semantics.
It would be great if we could actually get to the point of OP after all this time. How about we try doing that?
(The same could work from the demand-side of the equation as well. If you argue there is a significant amount of the population of software users that say are more concerned about the software "to be local-data first" than "the software must help me do my job faster/make me more money/get laid tonight", then you have a point. And no, pointing out to Richard Stallman and saying "well, actually there is this guy and a bunch of other aspies that don't care about getting laid or more money" is not really a valid refutation of OP's point)
I did just do that in my previous post and noted that my point does not change, but hey, please go right ahead and keep telling me what point I should be discussing and what it is that others meant to say.
Well, I was mainly responding to the closing paragraph.
>So yeah, sure, if you were to build a piece of desktop software from a clean sheet of paper today, this is a really good guide on how to do that. But nobody is going to. Because it makes no business sense to do so.
I could be more charitable and invent other things that I think they meant to say rather than focus on what they said. You are not the first to suggest it is a failing of mine that I do not do this.
Personally I think that if someone says say "But nobody is going to. Because it makes no business sense to do so.", it is reasonable to point out that there are plenty of motivations beyond 'business sense', and to point this out is fair comment, rather than getting hung up on anything.