News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by apo on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:52AM (#19817533)
Spam countermeasures have led to some fascinating new technologies. In addition to the one cited in the article was Hashcash, which was developed a few years earlier:

http://www.hashcash.org/papers/hashcash.pdf

Hashcash requires the sender to expend a small quantity of computational work, and attach a proof of this to the email before a recipient even opens it. The underlying assumption is that the burden would be insignificant for a real email sender, but onerous for a spammer.

The approach inspired the powerful anti-spam system at the center of Bitcoin.

It might be interesting to catalog all of the most innovative early approaches to combating spam, and the unrelated technologies that later arose from them.

Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by wereHamster on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:03AM (#19817585)
I recently came across this idea to prevent friend request spam on social media, using the Lightning network. The idea is that the person sending you the friend request must attach a small amount of money (in the form of a special lightning payment). If the friend request is legitimate, you can accept it (and not claim the money). But if it's spam you reject the friend request but take the money instead. This is different than Hashcash in that it incurs real monetary costs to the attacker. Instead of using compute resources (for the mining algorithm), the money would actually end up in your pocket.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by Retric on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:58AM (#19817977)
A much older example is the high cost of sending text messages basically eliminates text message spam.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by oarsinsync on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:23AM (#19818688)
Except the cost of phone calls, text messages and even postal mail is sufficiently low to result in spam across all three mediums in ever larger quantities than before
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by chrismeller on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:08AM (#19819084)
As he said, it is a much older version. As with everything the cost decreases over time to the point that it no longer outweighs benefit.

Put another way, this is the unfortunate flip side of free unlimited talk and text.

Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by sseveran on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:12AM (#19818575)
I don't think this would work in real life. When Bill Gates was proposing something similar, one of the engineers on the anti-spam team built an FPGA that would allow a spammer to solve such puzzles quickly enough to prevent spamming. His observation to me was that even though such a technique would work, botnets had eliminated the need for specialized hardware.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by Tharkun on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:28AM (#19818750)
Not to mention that spam is frequently sent by pwnd boxen or botnets. Why would the attacker care that it racks up someone else's electricity bill?
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by jaden on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:32AM (#19818219)
How does that work for free email newsletters? They're typically already paying an email service provider. Having to pay even more could be onerous for large, double opt-in lists, even though they're not spamming.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by pavel_lishin on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:45AM (#19818372)
I'm guessing that 99% of newsletters are sending vastly fewer messages than the people who send me half a dozen "Welcome to Adulte Sex " messages a day.
Re:Paul Graham provides answer to spam emails (2002) by sp332 on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:03AM (#19818499)
Maybe, but spammers are also more likely to be sending from rented botnets that can handle the increase in CPU usage spread over a large number of other people's computers.