News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by mistrial9 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:41PM (#19811894)
playing a lot of scrabble -- our regular play includes a list of two-letter words on paper, in pencil, nearby to settle disputes (not visible during play). The arguments get heated ! .. (our list is smaller than the official list of two letter words, based on mutual agreement of real-world use). Personal opinion is that the official list is already too broad, and makes the play "muddy." Dictionary exploration is nerd-fun! We use a 1950s Webster's Unabridged English (which webster? have to check) and a 1980s Oxford American-English; both have their quirks ! happy SCRABBLE™
Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by Theodores on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:36PM (#19812602)
It used to be 102 two letter words that were allowed, memorising all of them was not difficult, you would just know them if you played fairly regularly. Occasional players (who you probably wouldn't be playing with if you played regularly) would not know the 102 two letter words. Slightly more to remember than the alphabet, but anything wrong on the board would be easy to spot as wrong, no risk in making a challenge.

As for dictionaries, mobile phones and apps changed everything. However, before these 'advances' the dictionary to use was the correct Scrabble one.

What I liked about the proper Scrabble dictionary was that none of the words were explained. So you could play words beyond your normal level of spoken English without knowing what they meant, but you would know they were in the proper Scrabble dictionary. So you could have 'ax' and not know what it meant or extend it on the next go to 'axon' with no idea what that meant. You did know from previous games that this was legit and that was all that mattered.

To people not in the game this dictionary seemed absurd. The language had morphed into code. A code that you had to know if you were ever to have a chance of using complete 7 letter 'laydowns' several times in a game and do those cool two letter joins to make such things possible.

Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:47PM (#19811970)
How is keeping a handwritten list of words any different than violating the rule against using a dictionary to find words, though?

Most of the hardcore Scrabble people I've known would object to that. ("This isn't 'Nam, there are rules.")

Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by dmurray on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:00PM (#19812123)
I doubt that actual hardcore Scrabble players would care, any more than a hardcore chess player would mind if you kept referring to an index card with a diagram to remind you which way the horsey moves. Of course, they would care about you having access to the entire dictionary, just as a serious chess player would object to you having a collection of chess opening or endgame reference books to hand.

At a beginner level, it's more fun when no one knows the word list perfectly, and you shouldn't allow it.

At a slightly-above-beginner level, say where one player knows the two-letter words and others do not, knowing the two-letter words is such a huge advantage that it's a sensible house rule to level the playing field a little, and likely make it more fun for both.

Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by diminoten on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:06PM (#19812934)
I think a serious chess player would mind if you were consulting a list of opening moves, though...
Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by vkou on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:21PM (#19812395)
A serious chess player would play timed games, and if you want to spend your time leafing through a dead tree book... It's your time to waste.
Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by blotter_paper on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:48PM (#19811978)
> the regular players have a list of two-letter words on paper, in pencil, at hand.

No, this is against the rules. You know what we call a list of words? A dictionary. You aren't allowed to have those open until a word gets challenged. A decade ago I had all the two letter words in the Scrabble dictionary memorized, I doubt I'd still be able to spit them all out.

Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by TimTheTinker on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:13PM (#19812298)
OP said it wasn't visible during play, only as a quick reference when resolving disputes -- quicker than hunting through a full-size dictionary.

> No, this is against the rules.

It wasn't, but even if it was, that's only the official rules. We can choose to play by different rules.

Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by blotter_paper on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:57PM (#19812832)
I'm pretty sure he edited that comment without noting it, the current text doesn't match what I quoted. I do think I misread his intent, but I don't think he originally said that it was just for resolving disputes or specified that it wasn't visible during play. You can see other comments reacting in line with my original interpretation, too.
Re:Scrabble rule change allows use of 'OK' by rhcom2 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:51PM (#19812020)
It's a pretty common house rule for casual players.