News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by Agustus on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:16AM (#19808740)
The point of this policy is to identify real familial relations with those crossing the border.

At the border there are instances of individuals using children to get special preference. The proposed idea will mitigate this issue.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mchristen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:26AM (#19808858)
Can you define "real familial relations" purely by DNA? I don't think so, what about adoptions or surrogates?

This just seems like a policy that can be used to discriminate against people who don't fit a chosen definition of "family".

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by creaghpatr on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#19809007)
Or it can be used to expedite the clearance of real families instead of subjecting everyone to the same questioning methods.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by thex10 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:59AM (#19809307)
> real families

That's... still discriminating against people who don't fit a chosen definition of "family"

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:06PM (#19809377)
But then they won’t be claiming “this is my daughter/son”...

They’re trying to filter against bogus claims.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by tyingq on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:37PM (#19810358)
There will certainly be some guys traveling with a child they believe to be theirs. Until the test comes back.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:02PM (#19810639)
Won’t most the cases be either mother-child or mother-(adult male)-child? I don’t see father-child being the predominant grouping.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by roywiggins on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#19809420)
And people with adoptive children will say what, exactly?
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:10PM (#19809433)
Presumably they can provide papers to the effect. Just as if I were to claim asylum in any other place.

Also, I’m sure they have rates of these things and if it starts getting higher than the norm it could prompt more scrutiny.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by roywiggins on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:12PM (#19809459)
People fleeing for their lives may not have access to paperwork. In fact, the authorities denying people access to paperwork- such as birth records and legal status- is almost certainly evidence for approving an asylum claim in the first place.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:15PM (#19809483)
Do you think the instances “fleeing” is the bulk of the cases? Mostly it’s economic migrants. We know if they were fleeing they could just stay in Mexico or if not from The Americas, in a neighboring country.

Also, in many of those countries there isn’t a tradition of adoption, so that would be pretty rare.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by dragonwriter on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:58PM (#19809939)
> Do you think the instances “fleeing” is the bulk of the cases?

By definition, it's 100% of the cases that would be legitimate before validating the family relationship.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by roywiggins on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:19PM (#19809530)
It's not that uncommon.

> Many of the migrants are asylum seekers fleeing political violence in their countries of origin, especially Congo and Cameroon. Many of the Congolese lived for years in Angola, where they learned enough Portuguese to get by in Spanish. Angola last year expelled more than 300,000 Congolese refugees.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/hundreds-o...

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:22PM (#19809559)
Angola is one of the up and coming countries in Africa. That people are leaving it indicates it’s more an economic calculus than persecution.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by dragonwriter on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:00PM (#19809960)
> Angola is one of the up and coming countries in Africa. That people are leaving it indicates it’s more an economic calculus than persecution

The US was the up-and-coming nation of the Western hemisphere for a long time while engaging in systematic persecution of blacks, Native Americans, and, at various times and places, other groups. Aggregate economic development and systematic persecution of selected groups which justifies flight in reasonable fear aren't mutually incompatible.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by roywiggins on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:32PM (#19809669)
> The destruction in Kapende, where no house remains occupied or intact, marked the culmination of three days of violence in Lucapa, a sprawling mining town in the northeast surrounded by some of the world’s richest diamond fields.

> About 300,000 Congolese have fled Angola in the last few weeks, many of them in response to the violence in Lucapa at the beginning of October.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-angola-drc-violence-insig...

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by astura on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:47PM (#19810469)
Not all adoptions are "official" and "have papers," especially adoptions by people who are fleeing their country. I would argue that most adoptions in so-called "third world countries" are probably unofficial.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mc32 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:55PM (#19810566)
That’s possible but also adoptions aren’t as common as in the US. I’ve had conversations with people from some of these areas and adoption is hardly considered as an option to adding to a family.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by astura on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:01PM (#19810621)
Huh? You have an extremely narrow view of adoption, I would assume most "unofficial" adoptions are by circumstance, not a generic desire to add to the family.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by a_random_name on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:44AM (#19818359)
I'm an adoptive parent in the US and I've been waiting months for that paperwork........
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by logfromblammo on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:02PM (#19809981)
Requiring papers to prove one's own identity and familial relationships is anathema to the traditions of Common Law.

Of course, this tradition is being undermined left and right for the sake of the convenience, prejudices, and the power to control, of the ruling classes. And we go along with it, because there are some defensible reasons for doing so.

It's why I prefer online services that allow users to pick their own names. Here, I'm logfromblammo, and that's all anybody needs to know about me. In contrast, on Facebook, the terms of service require me to link my account to the identity I use for official interactions with the government, which is in turn linked to the name my parents gave me at birth.

Without descending into the identity derpfest propagated by some right-leaning libertarians, controlling my own identity means that it is more difficult to hurt me by hacking documents linked to my government identity. The more private businesses use the government identity exclusively, the more identity fraud and identity theft can become a problem.

This type of DNA-collecting dragnet reinforces the paradigm "you are who the government/company/computer says you are" over "you are who you claim to be". Getting sent to the vice principal's office to be disciplined for something that another person, enrolled at my high school with the same name as mine, had done is as close as I ever want to get to that. I got yelled at, for their mistake in identification. I am the only person who can really be sure that I am me, and I don't trust others not to screw that up--because they keep on screwing it up.

Asking for someone's "papers" to prove anything is never going to be something I could support unconditionally. Whenever you do that, you're taking away someone's agency to be in control of their own life.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by sszz on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:32AM (#19808949)
It would mitigate this issue to an extent, but also introduces new challenges (for instance and as pointed to elsewhere: dealing with officially/unofficially adopted children). I'm not sure if there are published numbers on what fraction of adult asylum seekers are attempting to use children in this way, but the preoccupation with "solving" this particular issue demonstrates that either (a) that fraction is disturbingly high or (b) we'd like to make the process even more complicated for no particularly good reason. The trend of every policy along the border seems to suggest that (b) is more likely, which is upsetting.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by klyrs on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:27AM (#19808872)
Good to know that adoptions aren't "real." So if a kid's parent dies and they're living with an aunt, that's not "real" and the government is free to tear the child's remaining family away and replace it with rape and imprisonment.

Way to mitigate the issue. Damn the consequences.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by LoSboccacc on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:31AM (#19808924)
adoptions have a paper trail.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by sszz on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:36AM (#19808996)
Not a given, particularly for people fleeing countries in crisis, disarray, or violent turmoil. Or if a parent died during the migration, etc.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by LoSboccacc on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:50AM (#19809209)
> if a parent died during the migration

so if a parent dies any rando in the caravan can claim the child and get all the attached benefits? gee, wonder if that kind of reward would have side effects on the safety of migrants with children.

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by pjc50 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:11PM (#19809447)
What "benefits" are you talking about?
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by mfatica on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:15PM (#19810118)
Migrants at the border are handled with different policies if they arrive with children rather than alone
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by astazangasta on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:47AM (#19809171)
Births don't even have a paper trail in much of the world.
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by sDlEzAtyoNAz on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:00PM (#19809955)
Do non-familial adoptions actually happen in any sort of significant numbers in central american countries?
Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by SolaceQuantum on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:25PM (#19810252)
I'd actually like to know if blended families occur more often than "child recycling". (Blended Families == adoption, divorce and remarriage, godfathering/godmothering, other culturally normatized familial-like relationships that aren't necessarily accepted as a "nuclear family"...)

(Disclaimer: I have no real opinions on this, but I'd like to get the facts.)

Re:DHS to start DNA testing to establish family relationship... by a_random_name on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:25AM (#19808841)
This makes a lot of presumptuous about the intention of the adults here. Do you know that these are not something similar to adoptive parents?!