Re:The V-2
by maxxxxx on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @06:28PM
(#19802313)
As a German I have very mixed feelings about von Braun. On the hand he was an impressive engineering leader but he was also a war criminal that used slave labor under terrible conditions without hesitation. I would have prefer him going to jail for a few years after the war.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
On the plus side, he helped the Nazis waste a tremendous amount of resources that could have prolonged the war if used more effectively. I don’t know how much credit you can give him for that since it wasn’t his intent, but it’s something.
On the V2, or something else?
On the V-2. It cost the Germans more than it cost the Americans to develop the atomic bomb, and had no military benefit for the Germans.
Not specifically disagreeing with the "no military benefit" but this is a map of V-2 use on England. https://www.wrsonline.co.uk/big-ben-rocket-strikes/1944-v2-r...
Now compare with the locations of military bases, war-related factories, etc.
It’s not precisely zero. The civilian casualties had an economic impact which would have affected the war effort, and at least a few soldiers were killed as well. But it’s negligible.
Most notably, the Americans had more funds to burn through..
Right. It’s not that it cost them more, relative to their much smaller economy. It just cost more, period.