News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cosmology Has Some Big Problems by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:48PM (#19800913)
Well... assuming that the local rules are the same as the rules billions of light-years away is an assumption, based on a philosophical presupposition that the rules are uniform. What probability should we assign to that assumption? 100% in the absence of evidence to the contrary? Or should we reserve some skepticism, remembering that it is an assumption?

Your question is reasonable: Have people formulated specific breakdowns, and gone looking? But it's also unreasonable. An assumption shouldn't necessarily be treated beyond plausible doubt until we can prove it wrong.

Re:Cosmology Has Some Big Problems by jerf on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @04:00PM (#19801023)
"Have people formulated specific breakdowns, and goon looking?"

They have. Considerable effort has been expended trying to detect changes in various constants related to light, including speed but also some other things. It is expected that if constants were changing, spectra would change as well. So far as I know, all those results have been negative, but it's not for lack of trying. Similar arguments can be deployed for the nuclear forces as well w.r.t. spectrum, rates of fusion, various things you'd be able to observe in certain types of supernovae, etc.

One of the things I don't like about this genre of articles is that it's typically quite mistaken, if not outright disingenuous, about the current state of cosmology. From what I could see, the idea that cosmologists are all stodgy old fogies brought up in a paradigm of the Big Bang and who won't entertain any other thoughts is diametrically opposed to the truth. To my eyes, the field is a bubbling cauldron of various exotic ideas and attempts to resolve all these issues. There's no lack of theories in cosmology and attempts to resolve these issues, including many quite radical ones (the holographic principle, changing constants over time, heck even "Dark Energy" is quite radical in many ways even if it is also the accepted theory at the moment).

What we lack are theories that explain all the observations. Dark matter is favored not because it's the only idea that anyone has come up with, but because it's still the one that best fits the facts. (As PBS Space Time pointed out last week, ironically, the galaxies recently discovered to not contain dark matter are themselves quite strong evidence dark matter must exist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5t0jaE--l0Y , because almost all other theories to explain galactic rotations are based on characteristics that can not vary by galaxy like matter distributions can. "MOND", for instance, is not "MOND, except in these two galaxies".)

If you can solve all these problems, as near as I can tell, you'll be celebrated, not shut down by the old fogerati. But be prepared for your theory to need to cover a lot of existing observations; we're centuries past "Well, what if gravity just worked differently?" or "What if the constants aren't constant?" You're going to need a great deal more detail than that.