Re:Thou Shalt Not Lie: git rebase, ammend, squash, and other...
by pjstadig on Tuesday December 07, 2010 @01:08PM
(#1979933)
That's an interesting response given that I spent quite a few words talking about how great `git blame`, `git bisect`, `git rerere`, and `git branch --contains` are and why rewriting history breaks them. Was it tl;dr? Or did I not get my point across effectively?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Thou Shalt Not Lie: git rebase, ammend, squash, and other...
by gxti on Tuesday December 07, 2010 @03:07PM
(#1980387)
You didn't explain why rewriting local, private history breaks any of those things unless you keep your local, private branches around indefinitely in un-rewritten form. If I rebase, it replaces my previous branch, not extends it. `git rebase` only breaks bisection if you are using it incorrectly (on public commits).