They don't pay list prices either, and have negotiated something much less. The list prices are basically a fantasy hoping to gouge the unknowing, while the rest of us feel like we got a discount.

It's simple fraud in many cases.

Patient has a 20% copay. The provider bills $100,000. The provider "pays" $80,000. The patient pays $20,000.

Provider then pays a $70k kickback disguised as a discount on other charges, fees for participation in the system, etc. (or never even pays the EOB amount). In fact a total of $30k is paid for the services, and 66% of that comes from the patient.

Insurance gets away paying $10k instead of $24k (80% of $30k). Provider gets the business by being on insurer's provider list. Patient thinks "I'm glad I paid $20k for Insurance. My health-care-spend ended up being $40k instead of $100k." In fact, they'd have been better off without insurance, which would have only cost $30k.

are you claiming most people don't have deductibles and copays? or no in & out of network coverage. if so I'll call BS on this. I've had instances of being billed from out of network provider even though I went to in-network hospital. this is such a common occurrence that John Oliver did an episode on it.