Agreed. I'd like to see more detail. C.f. facebook's recent post-mortem (http://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-engineering/more-deta...). Lots of detail. When a downtime blog post is so vague like Tumblr's was, my first instinct is that there's something they are deliberately not telling about what went wrong. Or maybe they haven't figured out exactly why it went down yet. I hope a more detailed postmortem is coming.
On a side note - anyone know what DB they are using? The cynic in me is thinking "Hey, another MongoDB + FourSquare 'success' story of webscale awesomeness."