News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:14PM (#19780327)
If you have a profound negative reaction to someone purporting to advocate social justice, frankly I think it's very very likely the problem is on your end.

It's true that someone can advocate a thing ineffectively, or miss some finer point, or claim to be about justice but advocating something else. But one must consider their intentions. Likely they are good, and your alleged conflict with them is a misunderstanding. So don't take it as a personal attack and you'll likely be fine. If you feel they are excluding you, very likely they are not intending to do so. You can try to ask them politely if you have any doubt.

[Full disclosure: I am a left-wing person and likely you would call me an SJW.]

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by erentz on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:54PM (#19780758)
You’re accusing me of things that I am not and inferring things that aren’t in anyway implied in my comments. We likely exist in very close proximity on the political spectrum and you’ve maybe made an assumption I am not because in your mind only those on the right can be against the bad behaviors described.

A lot of people who engage in SJW behavior are indeed good at heart. A lot I would argue are also being used by bad actors. That doesn’t make the bad behaviors okay or free from criticism. It’s a scary world where that becomes mainstream.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:59PM (#19780804)
All I see is you're getting very defensive. Even if you are left or centrist, even as I read your reply, it's probably that you take the behavior personally. My reply was not to assume a right-winger, my reply is more along the lines of "why do you have this negative reaction?"

If you object, let it be known, ask for clarification. Perhaps the person you object to will open their mind to your concern too. Assuming "SJW" and ending it there is to keep the misunderstanding going.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by MrScruff on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:00PM (#19780814)
Isn't it part of the problem that left-leaning people consider themselves to have good intentions but consider right-leaning people to have bad intentions? Everyone is the hero of their own narrative.

While I would likely be more aligned politically with you than not, I also understand that there are many on the left that bring an aggression and intolerance to the policing of ideas and discussion that seems of little benefit to the world.

It seems to me we need more advocacy for self-reflection and less for people's individual belief systems.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:18PM (#19781011)
> Isn't it part of the problem that left-leaning people consider themselves to have good intentions but consider right-leaning people to have bad intentions?

Perhaps. But I didn't say that, and I'm not arguing that point. I read your point as a direct consequence of what I've written, actually.

But if I may argue that point for a bit, for the sake of argument, a lot of the "SJW" stuff that riles people up is to say that a protected class or minority should be allowed to exist, and people do react to that with what amounts to "your existence is offensive to me". Which is one reason I immediately jump into: why is the SJW offensive to people? Is it that the anti-SJW has some kind of hangup? Often, yes.

Just let them be. And they will let you be too. I know this is an unpopular opinion on HN and so I'm losing karma over it. OK.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by MrScruff on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:49PM (#19781371)
>Just let them be. And they will let you be too.

I think this is the point of contention. I don't think the type of person I'm describing will 'let you be' if you make an argument that falls outside their worldview. And the tone of the resulting debate is more often than not fairly toxic. The result is just more division.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:19PM (#19781684)
Sounds a lot like paranoia to me. What do you think will happen?
Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by MrScruff on Monday April 29, 2019 @04:21PM (#19782231)
I'm speaking from experience.

What happens is that strength of feeling is used as a substitute for quality of argument. Those that dissent are accused of insensitivity or worse.

Perhaps you've never had this experience but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:07PM (#19782625)
Ok. So if I may ask, what happened to you? If you don't want to say, that's fine.

I have had many kinds of ludicrous mistreatment or misunderstandings in life, but I try to not extrapolate them to all humanity, or even everyone expressing a political view, or even expect that they recur from the same set of characters.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by belorn on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @05:11AM (#19786294)
> a lot of the "SJW" stuff that riles people up is to say that a protected class or minority should be allowed to exist

I have tested this several time on HN, face to face and other places. I do this by suggesting that it should be made in to a generic law.

For example, when Muslim clothing is debated in the news someone from the "SJW" political side will eventually state that people should be free to decide what they wear. By forbidding burqa at work or public places, they say we deny that minority to exist. I bring up that I know a nudist who would very much like the freedom to decide what they wear, and who very much is denied to exist as a nudist at work and public places.

By turning what is advocated into a generic law that give everyone the same freedom, suddenly the interest from SJW drops.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by manigandham on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:35AM (#19788861)
>> a protected class or minority should be allowed to exist

This is the default view of 99.9% of people. If you want to battle the 0.1% of people who feel otherwise then fine but trying to say that is the majority position of everyone who doesn't think like you is the problem.

Similarly, using the term "exist" is uselessly hyperbolic. Communicating like this is usually not in good-faith, it's just antagonistic and unproductive.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:14AM (#19794490)
Sounds a lot like you got offended because you don't like the protected classes.

If this were not the case, I don't think you would have bothered with such a huffy, indignant response.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by pacala on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:20PM (#19781028)
What do you mean by "social justice"?
Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:25PM (#19781090)
Let's keep it simple and take the first definition of each word, per dictionary.com.

> the quality of being just; righteousness, equitableness, or moral rightness

> relating to, devoted to, or characterized by friendly companionship or relations

Sounds like a good idea to me.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by pacala on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:26PM (#19781104)
That is the definition of justice [0], and the definition of social [1]. What do you mean by "social justice"? Friendly righteousness?

Edit. To further clarify, help distinguish "social justice" from "colorless green ideas sleep furiously."

[0] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/justice

[1] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/social

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:40PM (#19781266)
> Friendly righteousness?

I'd much prefer the "equitable companionship" interpretation.

Kind sir or madam, I and my definition of "social justice" are not your enemy. You are a stranger to me but I trust you are able to interpret the phrase just as well as I, and hope that you can trust me to do the same. So do relax.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by pacala on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:46PM (#19781334)
How can you make moral judgements about "social justice" and its advocates/opponents, when you can't even define the term in your own words? I appreciate your instinct toward open and polite dialogue, I just don't see how that can work on a topic you can't propose a definition for.
Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:51PM (#19781397)
This is kind of facetious, my friend. You haven't asked me to define any other terms in the language we are using and yet you know what we are talking about.

Likely you have formed your own opinion about the term a priori that is incompatible with popular understanding, and you wish to make a point which is not relevant to my commentary.

I have given you everything you need to understand the comment. Cheers.

Edit: if you do really want me to expand, I do take it as the conjunction of two words, one implying fairness, and another implying people or society. I also recognize that many will interpret the phrase with emphasis on protected classes, or things that ought to be protected classes that may not legally be so. Fairness is a subjective term so people will disagree. My personal definition does not matter so much since this discussion is, far as I can tell, centered around people who are not me.

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by pacala on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:09PM (#19781577)
Most people have a fairness instinct. The fairness instinct has been observed even in monkeys [0]. Given that most people also live within a social fabric, it is not too hard to imagine that most people have an instinct for a fair society. Alas, this is simply too vague of a definition, as it encompasses most religious/philosophical/political perspectives out there, on the left as well as on the right [gasp!]. The modern "social justice" movement has a number of very specific insistences, which align with a much smaller subset of perspectives than the umbrella "fair society" ideal would imply. I simply want to have someone sympathetic to the modern "social justice" movement to state some specifics on what they mean by "social justice". Looks like you're not the right person, no worries. I'll keep asking. One day someone will answer.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKhAd0Tyny0

Re:Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation by asveikau on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:12PM (#19781616)
I don't honestly think there is a social justice movement. You are implying more organization than exists. That is why you can't find any.

AFAIK the term "sjw" was defined by those that oppose it.