News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikijerks by DanielBMarkham on Monday December 06, 2010 @10:43PM (#1977922)
What I'm saying is that if you believe the system itself is the problem, then nonviolent resistance all by yourself may not be effective.

I believe you are arguing that the individual should take various forms of action based on his/her best guess as to what the outcome might be. My point was that this is an individual choice based on internal criteria: going around guessing what outcome might happen from this, that, or the other action is not a basis for the choice to take action itself (although it might be a great basis for choosing the type of action) I don't decide to attack an intruder in my home based on some assessment of the possibilities of the various legal options I might have: I attack an intruder because I believe my life is in jeopardy. At the extremes the decision to act in such a blanket manner is an internal choice.

Let's hang it up here. Thanks for the conversation! I hear us both agreeing that the thought experiment was worthwhile. I plan on using that the next time the topic comes up. Maybe we can make more progress then.

There are no comments on this comment yet.