Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ...
by ncmncm on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:12AM
(#19775993)
Of course one would not burn pB in a tokamak. So, that number is not relevant, although it is always trotted out to justify not diverting money from tokamak.
Practical pB designs rely on colliding beams as in the LHC, or other plasma-dynamic schemes that engage the materials in their own confinement.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ...
by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:43AM
(#19777214)
Colliding beam schemes for p-11B will not work, as was shown by Rider and Nevins decades ago. This didn't stop TAE from selling such a scheme to investors, even though they were told it didn't work.
ITER's power density is 0.05 MW/m^3 (gross fusion power divided by volume of the reactor machinery; plasma volume is smaller). The power density of the MIT's ARC reactor is somewhat better, at 0.5 MW/m^3.
But the power density of a PWR reactor vessel is 20 MW/m^3, a factor of 40x better than ARC and 400x better than ITER.
Given that fusion reactors are much more intricate and use much more sophisticated materials and systems than a PWR reactor vessel, and are also much larger, the fusion reactors cannot help but be much more expensive per unit of thermal power output than fission reactors.
BTW, the main reason p11B fusion gets less investment is that for a given magnetic field the peak fusion rate of a p11B plasma is three orders of magnitude worse than for DT.