News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by IMTDb on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:45PM (#19773578)
I am always amazed by the (low) price of those projects, compared to the potential benefits

$890 million for potentially giving a new clean energy source seems incredibly low. I can't see a reason why we don't have at least 10 of those projects being concurrently funded in the US, Europe and China. This is a fraction of a percent of the annual budget of each region.

Whoever gets their hand on that first is going to have a massive economical - and probably military - advantage over the others.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by maxxxxx on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:10PM (#19775031)
"I can't see a reason why we don't have at least 10 of those projects being concurrently funded in the US, Europe and China. "

I think it's the same reason why scaling up a dev team by 10x doesn't produce much more output in the same time. There are a lot of open questions in fusion that need to be worked out. Until one day someone will be able to put all partial solutions together into a working system. In the end it just takes time to try things, fail a few times and learn from others' failures.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by adrianN on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:27AM (#19776939)
There are several potential routes to fusion, the tokamak design is just one of them. We could pursue all options simultaneously.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by maxxxxx on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:12AM (#19779060)
Isn’t that’s what’s happening? ITER is a tokamak, Germany has built a stellarator. Other countries have smaller experiments. Right now nobody has a clear path to a commercial plant so they all try things and see which one works best in reality.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by adrianN on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:22AM (#19779163)
Tokamak research gets almost all the funding.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by hannob on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:32PM (#19773836)
> I am always amazed by the (low) price of those projects, compared to the potential benefits

What would be the potential benefit?

In an optimistic scenario you'd end up with a technology that will likely have very high capital costs for construction and also very high infrastructure costs for transmission lines, because you create a lot of energy in one location.

Even in that best case I don't see such a technology playing a huge role in a future energy system. You end up competing with Wind, Solar and Storage decades into the future (i.e. they'll be much cheaper than they already are today).

Of course there's also the much more likely case: It just won't work.

Given that there are much more pressing needs in energy research (how do we manage storage once we get to higher rates of renewables? how do we decarbonize sectors outside of electricity?) there isn't that much in favor of fusion imho.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by moosey on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:50PM (#19773929)
I surmise that effective fusion power would completely alter the space race forever, even before we figure out propulsion from this energy source. The scientific benefits from a potential large scale space platform with that kind of energy input would have enormity beyond measure, I'm sure.

Even if we don't leave the planet, the amount of energy that can be produced from a fusion plant would still offer tremendous benefits. You could run massive technological infrastructure directly around such a power source.

While one could say that humans themselves have little use of such a thing, I argue that fusion power could usher in a new age of humanity, despite the cost.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by jcoleh on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:35PM (#19775411)
The potential benefit is lots of electricity, which may be abundant that when amortized over the "high capital costs" could be much more cost effective than wind, solar, and storage, or may not be. We have to invest in these relatively small projects to figure that out.

Furthermore, the highly geographically concentrated energy production from fusion power could work really well for energy consumers with a similarly localized nature. I'm thinking large scale carbon capture, energy intensive materials manufacturing or processing, or large scale ocean water desalination.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:43PM (#19775427)
No, actually fusion is likely to be even more expensive than fission, and fission already cannot compete with wind and solar. Fusion takes the biggest problem of fission, high capital cost, and makes it worse, while reducing fuel costs, which are only a minor part of the cost of fission. It's bass-ackwards engineering.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by ThomPete on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:14PM (#19774069)
That line of reasoning sounds backwards.

The benefits would be clean, limitless energy and why is it likely that it will have a high capital cost and why wouldn't that be dwarfed by the availability of clean, limitless energy?

Claiming that somehow storage for renewables is a much more useful goal sounds more like ideology than anything.

Take the money currently going into solar and wind and put it to use there instead.

Solar and wind will never provide anything even close to what is needed for the energy needs of future generations or for any kind of progress in ex space exploration.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:34PM (#19775407)
The high capital cost of fusion follows from some fundamental aspects of fusion reactor engineering.

http://orcutt.net/weblog/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/The-Trou...

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by ThomPete on Monday April 29, 2019 @05:59AM (#19777060)
“Long touted as an inexhaustible energy source for the next century, fusion as it is now being developed will almost certainly be too expensive and unreliable for commercial use.”

"As it is now being developed"

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:41AM (#19777208)
Lidsky was advocating movement to advanced fuels. Unfortunately, his PhD student Todd Rider shot down most of those schemes (the ones using non-Maxwellian plasmas). After that, Lidsky transitioned to fission and spent the rest of his career working on that.

If fusion is to have a glimmer of hope, it's D-3He (which produces maybe 5% of the neutrons of DT). But 3He is very difficult to get. Mining the moon for it is probably impractical, because the concentration of 3He in the regolith is too low (and the moon could only power Earth for about 1000 years even if it could be mined).

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by ThomPete on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:26AM (#19777376)
The future is a long time. Most breakthrough technologies are based on often decades or even centuries of research.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:17AM (#19777594)
Perhaps. On the other hand, there are many more technologies than there are market niches for them to fill, so most technologies will be losers.

I see nothing that tells me fusion won't be a loser. The attachment some people have to it is bizarre. It's like they were told when they were young and naive that fusion was going to be the future, and are unable to revise their programmed opinions in light of contrary evidence.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by ThomPete on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:28AM (#19778141)
Well I can tell you for sure that wind and solar are loosers.

So unless you have a better idea I have a hard time understanding what your point is.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:56AM (#19778363)
How can you tell that wind and solar are losers? Their market shares are expanding rapidly across the world. They seem to be winning in the marketplace, not losing.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by ThomPete on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:36AM (#19778710)
They provide less than 1% of the worlds energy needs and even if you project up to 2040 they are still only going to be providing around 3% of the worlds energy needs. How is that winning?

So perhaps you are the one who's been too tied to one specific narrative that's not holding up to reality.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:16AM (#19779097)
In the magical world in which your argument there would be correct, technologies jump from 0 to dominant market share in a single discontinuous leap.

But we do not live in that cartoon universe. Here in real world, market share increases nearly continuously. On the way from 0 to 100, it passes near all the intermediate points.

What distinguishes a losing technology is not that it ever had a low market share -- all winning technologies did at some point -- but that they stop growing, and start losing market share. That describes nuclear, not renewables.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by fma on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:21PM (#19774466)
Per the article..."Wu Songtao, a top Chinese engineer with ITER, conceded that China's technical capabilities on fusion still lag behind more developed countries, and that US and Japanese tokamaks have achieved more valuable overall results"
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by whatshisface on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:31PM (#19773830)
>Whoever gets their hand on that first is going to have a massive economical - and probably military - advantage over the others.

If you were China, would you rather fight the US military (not going to work), or fight the US grip on world power via oil? Wow, if China switches us all to batteries and fusion, the petro-dollar and Texas economy are done for. That's far more than any military threat could ever hope to achieve.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by darawk on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:49PM (#19775450)
Ya, but if China invents fusion power, it's not like it's going to stay in China. Inventing fusion power will (probably) not be a strategic advantage to the country that invents it. The technology will disseminate rapidly to the other major powers. What will happen is the middle east will stop being such a hot geopolitical issue, and will be relegated to the status of other countries that are important only insofar as their humanitarian crises are a source of guilt for richer countries.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by i_am_proteus on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:59PM (#19775490)
This project is part of ITER-- China's contribution to an international effort to make fusion power a reality.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by imtringued on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:20AM (#19777125)
The Texas economy is already done for in terms of oil extraction. Fracking won't be sustainable for more than a decade or two. The benefits of fusion power would actually cement US power through space exploration and colonization more than any other country.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by mhb on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:12PM (#19774047)
Isn't the reason we don't have these cheap fusion projects because they don't produce usable fusion? Otherwise why would ITER have cost $20B?
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by bufferoverflow on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:25PM (#19773795)
For just 10% of its military budget USA could have 71 of these running.

(I know, I know, of course, US labor is more costly than the Chinese).