News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikijerks by hugh3 on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:34PM (#1977297)
Y'know, I think danielbmarkham is wrong to call for the use of lethal force against wikileaks, but I think that his point deserves a counterargument, not just some outraged huffing and puffing.

So Daniel, here's why I think you're wrong.

Firstly, you're justifying this on the basis that what Wikileaks is doing is analogous to war against the US. But it's really only analogous to it, it's not an actual war. Nobody has been killed in this "war" yet, and I really don't see a reason to start.

Secondly, it would set a bad precedent. By all means we can assassinate Osama bin Laden, but if you scale that back to Julian Assange then who else can we justify assassinating? There's all sorts of individuals making weakly-analogous and ineffectual "war" upon the US Government from various extremal points on the political spectrum.

Thirdly, it's unnecessary. Even in an actual war, we prefer to capture rather than to kill unarmed men where possible. If Assange has broken US law then there's a perfectly reasonable set of procedures we can go through in order to put him on trial.

Fourthly, it would just be a public relations disaster for the US, in ways that I don't feel the need to explain.

In conclusion, Daniel, I know you were being hyperbolic with the kill-Assange thing, but I think you'll agree that under careful consideration of the options that it's probably not the best option.

Re:Wikijerks by jbooth on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:40PM (#1977317)
It's in no way analogous to war against the US. It's a publicity campaign against some people who are pulling some levers in the US.

As has been said a million other places, there's way more embarrassing stuff about other gov'ts than there is stuff about the US in these cables.

But all you see the news media talking about is "whether Assange is unamerican".

Cui bono?

Re:Wikijerks by hugh3 on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:44PM (#1977325)
I really haven't seen anyone talking about whether Assange is un-American.

Since he's an Australian, it's not much of a question to ask.

Re:Wikijerks by jbooth on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:51PM (#1977353)
Excuse me, anti-American.

But then, you knew what I meant, right? Glad to see that my typo was the most important part of the post.