News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:34PM (#19772048)
This may be how China wins. While the West has capitulated to the hippies in moving to renewables and conservation, China is investing in increasing energy production capacity through nuclear. (Not just research into fusion, they’ve got 20 fission reactors under construction right now.) More energy means more economic capabilities and more war making capabilities.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by jeandejean on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:57PM (#19772197)
If you read the article you'd realize they're still late compared to western nuclear technology. It's great that they invest a lot in the technology but that's both wrong and premature to award them any achievement.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by natechols on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:43PM (#19774610)
If you read the article even closer, you'd see that it's part of an international collaboration that includes nearly all of the advanced industrial nations, including the US. The entire point of ITER is to be a stepping-stone to commercial fusion power in the next few decades. As always it is certainly interesting news when Chinese mega-experiments are on parity with the US or Europe, but so far big fusion reactors are like Top-500 supercomputers in that respect - dual use technologies whose economic value is marginal at best.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:00PM (#19772206)
Sure we’re ahead. But we’ve stopped trying, and diverted our resources to dead end technology.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by selimthegrim on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:41PM (#19772455)
What exactly is dead end tech here? Dye sensitized solar?
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by eloff on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:39PM (#19772443)
Nuclear is dead end tech. Renewables are cheaper than nuclear without the PR problems or risks, and getting cheaper all the time. The future is solar, wind, and hydro with a lot of energy storage and long distance transmission.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:43PM (#19772467)
Renewables will, at best, allow us to maintain our current energy expenditures in a more sustainable manner. (If that.) But they are incredibly space inefficient. Nuclear is the only avenue for increasing our energy production by an order of magnitude or more. (Not to mention, there is no such thing is a solar powered attack submarine or aircraft carrier.)
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by eloff on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:40PM (#19773540)
I call bullshit. 12 million acres of solar panels could power the whole of the US. We already lease twice that amount to oil and gas and twice that too just growing corn for ethanol. Solar would actually be a more efficient usage of land than the status quo just in terms of energy production.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2019 @08:02PM (#19774721)
The competition isn’t oil and gas, it’s fission and fusion.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:47PM (#19775440)
Fission and fusion have already lost. As Amory Lovins has pointed out, just the non-nuclear part of a fusion power plant would make it too expensive to compete. The reactor itself would have to cost negative dollars for the whole power plant to be competitive, and that's unlikely.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/amorylovins/2014/09/07/fusion-p...

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by eloff on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:46AM (#19778805)
While this seems an unpopular opinion here, it's correct. The economics are such that fission is out of the game, and fusion is out before it even got a chance. Now maybe one day we're using so much land area for solar and wind that it changes the calculus. But at least for this century renewables are going to dominate.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by jfk13 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:08PM (#19773686)
Why should we want to increase our energy production by an order of magnitude?

Maybe a new generation needs to read E. F. Schumacher.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2019 @08:01PM (#19774714)
Building a fully electric transportation network, supporting a greater population, advanced weapons like rail guns, etc. You know, progress. The future. Maintaining our technological supremacy.

China, Russia, etc., aren’t going to be reading E.F. Schumacher. Energy production equals economic, military, and political power. Whoever figures out how to break past the fossil fuel bottleneck is going to own the future.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by chimpburger on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:49PM (#19775220)
And for space exploration. Nuclear propulsion would enable humans to reach Alpha Centauri within a lifetime.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:40PM (#19775422)
No, fusion could not allow humans to reach Alpha Centauri in a lifetime, unless you mean they flew through the Alpha Centauri system without stopping.

If you want human interstellar travel, that probably means beamed power propulsion. That's a better solution anyway, since it allows higher power density at the vehicle. There is no need for fusion for that.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by chimpburger on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:58PM (#19775486)
Let's restrict it to travel within the solar system. We'll need fusion to power all of those beams.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:04PM (#19775512)
Why is fusion needed to power the beams? Sunlight would work just fine.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by chimpburger on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:21PM (#19775583)
There is a cap on potential solar power generation. Compare the amount of power generated per square meter for a solar panel versus a nuclear power station. Nuclear reactors can be stacked vertically or located underground. Also it is ugly to have vast areas of the natural landscape covered in panels. Ugly waste of space.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:37AM (#19777195)
We're talking here about solar collectors IN SPACE, where the beam sources would be placed. The cap there is the entire output of the Sun.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by manigandham on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:47PM (#19781338)
So we can take over the galaxy.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by bilbo0s on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:08PM (#19772264)
The Chinese government can afford it.

If you want nuclear here in the US, the government has to kick in the lion's share of the funds for it. That's just the situation we're in. Even with no regulation and taxes at all, nuclear is just enormously expensive compared to just continuing to use coal, or just slapping up some windmills someplace.

People have to be willing to take the tax hit, one way or the other, to get nuclear. Witness Vogtie. Where the government has come to the rescue and made a law forbidding residents from buying the cheaper wind or coal power. Literally. No one can switch from using Vogtie power. That's the sort of assistance that nuclear needs. (Yes, I know that Vogtie is late and still over budget despite the unprecedented government assistance. But that only reinforces my point really. Even Vogtie, which now has guaranteed captive customers, still needs semi trailers full of cash to make it work.)

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:09PM (#19772643)
> Even with no regulation and taxes at all, nuclear is just enormously expensive compared to just continuing to use coal

Given access to enriched uranium and no regulation, a nuclear reactor is basically a high school science fair project.

In practice you're going to want a larger scale than that and a design from a team of professional engineers rather than a high school student, but it should still cost an order of magnitude less than it currently does, with the difference attributable primarily to regulatory compliance costs.

Some of those regulations are obviously important, but many of them are purposely designed to increase costs, lobbied for by competitors who want nuclear to be uneconomical.

Even a simple change like having the rules a plant is constructed under be the ones in effect when construction begins rather than when it ends would be a significant cost reduction, because as it is one of the major costs is that the rules for "new plants" often change after the relevant portion of the plant has already been constructed.

> People have to be willing to take the tax hit, one way or the other, to get nuclear.

Maybe we could just start by leveling the playing field. Renewables and fossil fuels are already directly and indirectly subsidized, either eliminate those or apply them equally to nuclear. We need to price carbon. Use the same standards for radioactive emissions for coal and nuclear. If you're going to require nuclear to pay up front for decommissioning and price in various other things then do the same for everything else etc.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by natechols on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:46PM (#19774626)
These are excellent points. If everyone was forced to pay the true cost of their energy consumption, including not just fuel and up-front capital costs but long-term environmental remediation, accident insurance, and so on, how expensive would the various technologies be?
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by bilbo0s on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:50PM (#19775456)
In complete fairness here, wind does have to pay "not just ... up-front capital costs but long-term environmental remediation, accident insurance, and so on". Farmers and the various states' departments of natural resources don't just hand over their land for free with no strings attached, and insurance on those windmills is not cheap.

Even so, it still comes in orders of magnitude cheaper than nuclear.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:25PM (#19775597)
People keep saying nuclear is really expensive.

https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/electri...

https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/08/f25/LCOE.pdf

Moreover, "orders of magnitude cheaper" means hundreds of times cheaper. You would have to be doing something silly like comparing one 3MW wind turbine to one 3000MW nuclear reactor.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:07AM (#19777314)
If you look at what nuclear power plants actually end up costing, they are very expensive. Paper studies that promise us otherwise don't make up for that. It's been the consistent history of nuclear power that those promises aren't worth the paper they're printed on.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by AnthonyMouse on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:12PM (#19779665)
Nuclear proponents: This should be cost effective.

Nuclear opponents: [Change laws/rules during construction to drive up costs on purpose; cost is now more than projected but still less than coal]

Nuclear opponents: Look at all these cost overruns. It now costs more than solar would if we solved the nighttime problem with hypothetical cheaper storage technology that doesn't currently exist, therefore nuclear is unviable and we should never attempt it again.

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:15PM (#19779689)
No, what actually happened was the nuclear vendors lowballed their bids, confident they could either reduce costs or get the customers to pony up more later. Regulation is just the excuse they gave when the inevitable happened.
Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by AnthonyMouse on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:32PM (#19779872)
That also happens, but that part happens with all construction projects from bridges to fiber rollouts -- including the construction of other types of power plants:

http://schlissel-technical.com/docs/reports_35.pdf

Re:The Anhei tokamak is first in the world to generate 100M ... by pfdietz on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:21PM (#19781040)
Utility scale PV typically comes in within 10% of estimates.