News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by duxup on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:05PM (#19758989)
How does this work financially?

I have a lot of vacant retail near me and they're nice spots, but the leases are all sky high. For whatever reason the folks making decisions about what goes in there are happy to sit and wait for yet another Noodles & Company or Chipotle, nails salon, but that's kinda it... and if not those places, empty.

I'd love to find good ways to encourage local shops and things beyond just the business with the highest margins.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by anbop on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:00PM (#19759578)
The owners of the building are sitting in the most enviable position in the economy — just by owning the asset, they will get money in the form of appreciation, from work done by other people.

The rent is the cherry on top and they’d rather just go for a contract with a safe mega corporation than deal with any actual work in interacting with a business.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ThrowawayIP on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:06PM (#19759623)
This is a great reason to have a local-level tax on vacant space. Both commercial and residential.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by monocasa on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:18PM (#19759742)
Meanwhile, here in my town, the landlords run the place and got the opposite passed. Commercial retail properties are exempt from property tax while the property is vacant.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by taurath on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:26PM (#19763574)
That sounds crazy - I wonder if that causes more or fewer derelict properties.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by monocasa on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:45AM (#19765782)
More. What they do is double the rent on businesses when their contract is up, and leave the derelict properties up as an example to the other businesses of "you have no negotiating power. We'll just leave the property empty if you don't pay up because it only has an opportunity cost"
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by SkyBelow on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:02PM (#19761704)
Why not tax the place based on the land value regardless of how it is being utilized? If there are too many vacancies then it would indicate the tax is too low and should be raised (or that the valuation of the land needs to be redone).
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by _red on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:30PM (#19761475)
Instead of being a defeatist, why not just invest in a REIT on Etrade and join the party?
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by mywittyname on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:34PM (#19761494)
I think the OP is considering social goods, not personal profit. Society benefits greatly from having low rents.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by zwkrt on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:39PM (#19761538)
What a horrible, misanthropic viewpoint!
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by FakeComments on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:04PM (#19761719)
The return from a REIT is negative when property values collapse due to social breakdown.

I want long term growth on a multi decade scale, ergo, I have to take lower immediate returns to support the ecosystem which generates those returns.

Your view is myopic, not perfectly rational.

And is an example of what goes wrong with hill climbing algorithms: local gradients can lead to globally unwanted outcomes.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by mruts on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:13AM (#19765325)
That’s a pretty terrible idea. Sure, maybe in Manhattan where the economy is good that would work, but in less prospereous places that’s just regressive and will cause the economy to get into a death spiral.

Here’s how that would work: 1. A couple stores owned by a landlord close down due to a recession or something.

2. Landlord has to keep the vacancies for awhile while he finds other renters.

3. He get’s levied the extra taxes due to the vacant properties. Now he really needs to get it off his books or find a renter.

4. He can’t find a renter because the economy is bad. So he tries to sell the properties.

5. He either doesn’t sell it, or sells it a big discount because the buyer needs to price in the tax premium.

6. Rinse and repeat.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:41PM (#19766356)
> That’s a pretty terrible idea. Sure, maybe in Manhattan where the economy is good that would work, but in less prospereous places that’s just regressive and will cause the economy to get into a death spiral.

> Here’s how that would work: 1. A couple stores owned by a landlord close down due to a recession or something.

> 2. Landlord has to keep the vacancies for awhile while he finds other renters.

> 3. He get’s levied the extra taxes due to the vacant properties. Now he really needs to get it off his books or find a renter.

> 4. He can’t find a renter because the economy is bad. So he tries to sell the properties.

> 5. He either doesn’t sell it, or sells it a big discount because the buyer needs to price in the tax premium.

> 6. Rinse and repeat.

If this is truly "rinse and repeat", since each subsequent sell results in a price discount, wouldn't the price eventually settle on what the market can bear?

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by mruts on Saturday April 27, 2019 @08:53PM (#19768630)
Look at Detroit, where the government was giving away houses for $50 (literally).
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by User23 on Friday April 26, 2019 @11:14PM (#19763542)
Problem is if landlords lower rents it reduces the computed capital value of the property. If there’s a mortgage this will trigger Bad Things.

Btw I also think excessive rents are strangling society, but it’s not as simple as it seems to fix.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:43PM (#19766370)
> Problem is if landlords lower rents it reduces the computed capital value of the property. If there’s a mortgage this will trigger Bad Things.

> Btw I also think excessive rents are strangling society, but it’s not as simple as it seems to fix.

But if the property is vacant, isn't the effective rent $0? I have no experience with commercial mortgage lending and appreciate more details on the Bad Things and why they don't occur without repricing rent.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by User23 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:12PM (#19766834)
I'm not an expert on the subject, but I did learn this from a banker who is. So here's a simple and hopefully not too wrong description. Commercial real estate is an investment property, and it's expected to return some percentage. For argument's sake let's just say 5%. So if the rent is reduced, that expected return holds constant, meaning the capital value of the building drops proportionately. With a mortgage, this can bring the owner into negative equity, and banks really dislike that in commercial real estate. On the other hand, if a space is empty, but for lease at "market rate" then that continues to be the value used for computing the capital value of the property.

Of course this means in some cities you have entire blocks with half the store fronts for lease at "market rate" sitting there for years. This is clearly lousy for everyone, so these perverse incentives ought to be fixed, but to be honest I have no idea how to do that practically and equitably.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:04PM (#19767343)
From your description, commercial real estate sounds like a bubble waiting to burst, in that vacant properties exist to prevent the mortgage from going underwater to protect the property owners.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by User23 on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:50PM (#19768795)
REITs are a very risky investment, yes. That's why they advertise to suckers on AM radio stations.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by slavik81 on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:38PM (#19760589)
A vacancy tax seems weird to me. It's effectively the same thing as a higher property tax, but with a discount for non-vacancy. That is, a discount for putting anything in that space. I just don't see why you would give out a discount without ensuring the use of the property is doing something that provides a public benefit.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by 4ntonius8lock on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:12PM (#19761775)
The way I see, to care for vacant property, you need police, roads, and a ton of infrastructure. This is also needed for property that is used.

A non-vacant used property will provide a city with money in the form of sales taxes, jobs, growth, fees and in general prosperity. A town with a ton of small independently owned shops and restaurants (a side effect of forcing property on the market) is more attractive than one with strip malls filled with franchises. It will make people want to live there and drive prices up.

Why should a vacant property pay the same tax? It's taking up the same and paying less, in fact, in many cases, the vacant property is pulling down the value of the city. It's only fair for the vacant property owner to have to pay to blight his community. Such an arrangement is dealing with externalized costs, which is one of the best functions of government.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by RaceWon on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:48AM (#19764580)
> The way I see, to care for vacant property,

The way I see it; an added tax will just be an encumbrance on the budding entrepreneur, who worked two jobs, and begged to get the financing on that property. She has dreams, passion and a vision--she rolled the dice and will be bankrupt if she doesn't execute and have a bit of luck.

> which is one of the best functions of government

In a free society, perhaps the best function of government (which is nothing more than a random collection of random people) is to be as invisible as possible, and not to try to ram their (here again--this random collection of random people) agenda down everyone else's throat, every single chance they get.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by 4ntonius8lock on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:37AM (#19766038)
Sorry if where you live they are random.

Where I live they are elected.

And while I feel for the entrepreneur, this type of tax won't affect them if they lease it out.

There is no way for everyone to be happy. Needs have to be prioritized (like the need of the city to be prosperous over the need of the landlord to squeeze a few more cents out of a place)

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by RaceWon on Saturday April 27, 2019 @01:22PM (#19766563)
> Where I live they are elected

Random people run for office and random people are elected. Some of these random folks Are even qualified for the posts they hold.

> this type of tax won't affect them if they lease it out.

That is simply not true. In your scenario my mythical entrepreneur has no choice, she can't afford to not lease it out to the lowest bidder.

> like the need of the city to be prosperous over the need of the landlord to squeeze a few more cents out of a place

You seem to have a bit of disdain for business owners and complete faith in your elected officials. My point of view is totally the opposite--it's the business owner's money, Not your elected random peeps money. Furthermore, do you think the business owner fervently desires her property be locted in a prosperous city--of course she does, but that doesn't mean she wants incompetent people who are smooth talking just wasting it.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by 4ntonius8lock on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:40PM (#19767502)
> Random people run for office and random people are elected.

If you choose to state something that is demonstratively false, then we can't converse. I truly wish you the best.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by RaceWon on Saturday April 27, 2019 @06:58PM (#19768154)
> If you choose to state something that is demonstratively false

You appear to believe that there is a systematic method in place for people who may or may not decide that they want to run for a political office: I submit that no such system exists--it is truly hit-or-miss, and utterly indiscriminate, or to put it another way; random people run for office and some of them are elected.

I too wish you well... ttyl

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by akincisor on Friday April 26, 2019 @06:47PM (#19762432)
Does this same logic apply to promote a Wealth Tax on people who have wealth that's being hoarded?
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by 4ntonius8lock on Saturday April 27, 2019 @11:43AM (#19766061)
Nope. You hoarding wealth won't make the neighborhood less appealing. The hoarder is not free loading.

New wealth can be created, we don't need yours. If your investment real estate is contributing $1/square foot in property taxes but everyone else's occupied property is contributing $5/square foot in wages, sales tax, property tax and municipal fees... then it makes sense to charge the free loaders. This isn't even dealing with the blight and community development points. Just from a financial perspective it makes sense.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by a1369209993 on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:28PM (#19763397)
Assuming you're talking about money, actually no. Money doesn't have any associated geometry or topology, ie one bit of money, unlike land, is pretty much equivalent to another. It would be like "hoarding" a bunch of land in the middle of nowhere: only a problem if you're taking up a significant fraction of the global supply.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by abathur on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:28PM (#19761009)
I've been mulling this a lot for a while now. I see so much vacant space and wonder how much of a boon it would be to small entrepreneurs and communities if the market were optimizing for filling a larger share of rental space.

I suppose it might be disappointing if the rents dropped and all it lured in were payday loan shops, and I imagine any tax enough to effect behavior will also induce some landlords to just fake occupancy to dodge the tax without the liabilities/risks of an additional business running onsite.

I'm a little skeptical (but maybe not pessimistic?) about how plausible it is to engineer public-benefit outcomes for this kind of space?

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by jdreyfuss on Friday April 26, 2019 @08:30PM (#19762943)
Vacant properties have a lot of negative externalities -- higher safety risks, reduction in the quality of a neighborhood and in foot traffic (harming other businesses), higher incidences of squatting/homeless encampments, etc.

A vacancy tax is an attempt to correct for those externalities and encourage better behavior from landlords. This is a situation where just having something is noticeably better than nothing at all.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by bluGill on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:33PM (#19761953)
Vacant property needs more police and fire protection. When someone is there they keep the "riff-raft" out.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by drb91 on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:20PM (#19760931)
> I just don't see why you would give out a discount without ensuring the use of the property is doing something that provides a public benefit.

Public benefit and the profit margin are inversely correlated. The idea that you can encourage any benefit without having public competition is laughable. There is no market effect that can encourage people to care about the public benefit over profits. The key is to remove the landlord from the equation entirely and de-commodify real estate, especially residential real estate.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lamarpye on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:39PM (#19760597)
That sounds like a great way to slow down real estate development. Make sure there is an additional cost if you oversupply the market.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ricardobeat on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:46PM (#19760662)
Sounds good. Careful, controlled growth is always better.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lamarpye on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:18PM (#19760911)
Really? Why is it always better? Does this rule only apply to real estate?
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by xtian on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:36PM (#19761070)
Why is uncontrolled growth better? Seems like it most often leads to waste. In the real estate context this manifests as ugly, unlivable spaces which become derelict as soon as the frenzy passes.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lamarpye on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:26PM (#19761439)
I didn't say uncontrolled growth was better, I said a vacant building tax would slow or restrict new development.

Of course there is waste, this is part of the cycle of boom and bust. The people that mistime the market will overbuild and lose their investment.

When the frenzy passes, house may stay empty, but the market will adjust. Fewer new houses will be build and people who stayed out of the market will have a chance to buy at cheaper prices.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by xtian on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:42PM (#19761558)
You can argue the degree to which growth is controlled but the alternative to “careful, controlled growth” is uncontrolled growth.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by bluGill on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:40PM (#19762003)
No, the alternative is less careful controlled growth. Uncontrolled growth is impossible: you need unlimited labor.

The market controls growth. Of course many factors manipulate the market (interest rates...). Boom/Bust is always going to be a factor because it isn't possible to know perfectly how much space we need before we need it. Boom/bust isn't even all bad, those who need space after the bust can get it cheap and start something interesting that they wouldn't otherwise) - artists for example need cheap space if they are to start a studio.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ricardobeat on Saturday April 27, 2019 @05:00PM (#19767595)
> The market controls growth

That sounds beautiful in theory. In practice, whoever has surplus capital controls it. Growth ends up a product of a few people's bets, and they can afford playing against the 'invisible hand' and making big mistakes. The human cost will be paid for by the communities where the game plays out.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by bluGill on Monday April 29, 2019 @08:23AM (#19777631)
Many people have surplus capital. They might not be willing to risk it, but they have it. I could cash in my retirement account for example. There are a lot of people who have this cash, and some make small bets all the time. Sure to do a large development costs a lot of money, but there are a lot of small projects that cost less, and they add up. 100 people putting in $5000 wouldn't be hard to find, and that can do a medium sized project.

In short I reject your pessimism.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by xtian on Friday April 26, 2019 @06:31PM (#19762306)
Why ask why careful controlled growth is always better if you believe it is the only option? The market doesn’t control anything. The word control implies some sort of telos which is not present in an aggregate of individual purchasing decisions.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:45PM (#19766379)
> I didn't say uncontrolled growth was better, I said a vacant building tax would slow or restrict new development.

> Of course there is waste, this is part of the cycle of boom and bust. The people that mistime the market will overbuild and lose their investment.

> When the frenzy passes, house may stay empty, but the market will adjust. Fewer new houses will be build and people who stayed out of the market will have a chance to buy at cheaper prices.

Why would there be new development in places with high vacancy? Wouldn't the community want new development to be hindered if most of downtown is empty already?

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by wtdata on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:56PM (#19760743)
The owners generally bought the building with the work done by them or their parents did. It's an investment.

Also, the kind narrative you are proposing - and that is taking more acceptance in society lately - only makes building owners more weary and afraid of renting directly to someone that might decide they are entitled to the space without paying their due rent, so yes, of course they choose more and more to have the protection from a safe mega corporation.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:47PM (#19766394)
> The owners generally bought the building with the work done by them or their parents did. It's an investment.

We aren't talking about the stock market here. If someone buys property that means someone else doesn't get it. Vacant properties have a negative impact on communities.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by macspoofing on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:07PM (#19761313)
>The owners of the building are sitting in the most enviable position in the economy — just by owning the asset, they will get money in the form of appreciation, from work done by other people.

You mean like a savings account? Or a treasury bond? Or stocks? Or gold? There is such a thing as opportunity cost. The money that went into buying the property, as well as the money continually spent in maintaining it (from repairs, to taxes, to insurance, to advertising for renters, to managing renters) could have been spent on something else, like an index fund - which, without any effort, could net you a nice 7% return.

You're also missing the risk profile. Property values could crash at any moment, and take all the capital along with it. It happened in 2008 to many people. Could happen again at any time. Historically, real estate hasn't been the best store of value nor provided the best rate of return on your investment.

If you think it's that easy, you should try it.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lamarpye on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:35PM (#19760570)
Really? They are in the best position?

I see articles all of the time saying the US has too much retail space: https://www.businessinsider.com/the-retail-apocalypse-has-of... https://www.forbes.com/sites/bisnow/2017/04/05/even-develope...

It is not clear to me, why their asset prices are going to go up if there is too much supply.

Also does the building owner actually "own" the building or are they paying off a commercial loan?

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by bongo662 on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:55PM (#19760726)
Probably highly dependent on the location of the actual retail space though, a run-down mall that's been vacant since the 90's will still be considered in those calculations of total retail space even though its highly undesirable.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ForHackernews on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:15PM (#19759089)
I've read some articles about that:

https://nypost.com/2014/04/26/the-hidden-proof-the-economy-i...

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/dec/24/new-york-re...

> In addition, he says, banks will devalue a property if it’s occupied by a small business, and increase it for a chain store. “There’s benefit to waiting for chain stores. If you are a hedge fund manager running a portfolio you leave it empty and take a write-off.”

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by swiley on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:35PM (#19759307)
That's so odd.

For me personally I'm making a decision about where to move after I graduate and I'm planning on living a little farther from where I work specifically to get away from all the samey chain restaurants (holy cow they're depressing) to be in a more densely populated area with more small businesses. I have a hard time imagining I'm alone.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by kevin_thibedeau on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:53PM (#19759486)
Old suburban areas of the Northeast are largely immune to the bland sameness of franchised businesses that pervades the US. There is little space to build out and liquor licensing can be problematic for chain restaurants.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by duxup on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:18PM (#19759126)
It certainly seems to be a nation wide problem.

It really sucks as it seems like economic activity just waiting to ... happen, but naw.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lotsofpulp on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:12PM (#19759677)
The "For whatever reason" is that the risk reward is not worth it to experiment with independents. Consumers have shown that they like the familiar by rewarding it financially. Real estate owners and fund managers aren't choosing to make less money, they just have data that shows what course of action likely leads to the highest returns. There are a few places with enough density and people that consciously like to go out and experiment with different vendors and whatnot, but not most places.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by duxup on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:41PM (#19760009)
What is the risk exactly?

Say a business signs a 2 year lease. They go out of business after 1 year.

They got ~1 year of lease payments compared to ... nothing.

That still seems like something.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by chasedehan on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:05PM (#19761723)
Many commercial leases will pay to make renovations up front based on signing a long term lease. Many of these renovations can be in excess of the entire first year's lease. These can be quite large expenses and the owner would need to make sure they could recoup the cost.

Some strip malls in less desireable areas work they way a residential lease would, but those wouldn't be the best place to do it.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by alexhutcheson on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:01PM (#19761271)
Commercial leases are normally much longer than residential leases: 5-10 years is typical. Restaurants also normally require extensive renovations to the space, which then have to be ripped out at additional cost to make the space usable for the next tenant.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by aeorgnoieang on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:00PM (#19761265)
I'm pretty sure commercial leases are more likely 10 year leases.

And I'd imagine the risk is broadly similar to residential rentals, e.g. trouble evicting tenants, the tenant damaging your property.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ghostly_s on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:04PM (#19760253)
Yes, but if $chain does decide to open a location in the neighborhood in month 10 of that 2-year lease, it moves in to your competitor's building across the street, then you're stuck with the empty storefront again in a year while they have a nice indefinite recurring revenue stream.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by luckylion on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:14PM (#19760880)
> then you're stuck with the empty storefront again in a year while they have a nice indefinite recurring revenue stream

So that risk is worse than ... being stuck with an empty storefront?

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by perfmode on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:32PM (#19760536)
The building across the street isn’t ones “competitor”.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by sbzodnsbd on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:44PM (#19761123)
For the property owner they are
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by intrasight on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:11PM (#19759040)
Isn't so much "highest margins" as "deepest pockets". I would think that an independent business can have margins as high or higher than a chain.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by lotsofpulp on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:07PM (#19759639)
Assuming people value the outputs of both businesses the same (i.e. the chain will get paid just as much as the independent business), economies of scale should let the chain have higher margins.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by monocasa on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:05PM (#19760265)
Here in Boulder, there's a number of retail spaces that essientially can't turn a profit on it's own. Just The North Face, Prana, or Freepeople want a Boulder location so bad for marketing purposes, they're willing to keep the store running at a loss.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by intrasight on Friday April 26, 2019 @02:32PM (#19760526)
I'd not considered that in a hot location with limited retail space that companies might occupy that space at a loss and treat it as a marketing expense. But upon further reflection, I have to assume that is the case for a lot of business in Times Square, for example.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by macspoofing on Friday April 26, 2019 @04:03PM (#19761285)
>How does this work financially?

Not well. Retail is hard in the best of times.

>For whatever reason the folks making decisions about what goes in there are happy to sit and wait for yet another Noodles & Company or Chipotle, nails salon, but that's kinda it

Maybe the owners can't get anyone to rent the properties?

I doubt they are 'happy to sit and wait' for anyone. They still have to pay property taxes.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by basetop on Friday April 26, 2019 @06:41PM (#19762379)
It probably won't for the long term. These "feel good" stories abound when times are good. Wait a few years and reality sets in ( even quicker if a recession hits ).

Maybe if they copy B&N's model and turn themselves into a coffee shop that sells books on the side, it might work. But they'd need the scale of B&N and locations near major universities with wealthy privileged students willing shells out lots of money for lots of books that their professors recommend.

In an environment of online shopping and expanding library services, bookstores face a lot of headwind. Why would you go to a bookstore when you can go to the library? Why would you buy can carry a bunch of books home when you can just order it online? If you can solve these problems, you could make a lot of money opening up bookstores all over the country.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by ethagknight on Friday April 26, 2019 @07:06PM (#19762536)
It’s less than ideal. Even a small retail shop requires some new investment, and it’s probably coming from the landlord. Spending $100k minimum, probably far more, to outfit a space for a untested or low credit tenant is a gamble with very limited upside. That’s why landlords will sit and wait, and it’s not a pretty situation to be in as investor. A bookstore should be more doable, but it still requires someone to fill the store full of books that it believes it can sell. 10,000 books cost a lot to stock too.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by rfrey on Friday April 26, 2019 @07:22PM (#19762630)
At least in Toronto and Edmonton, the two places I have been involved with commercial real estate, I have never heard of a landlord footing the bill to outfit a space.
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by vageli on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:51PM (#19766416)
> At least in Toronto and Edmonton, the two places I have been involved with commercial real estate, I have never heard of a landlord footing the bill to outfit a space.

In the United States at least, many commerical real estate owners _will_ perform a build-out conditional on a lease agreement. Of course, if the business folds earlier than expected it is the real estate owners who have to eat the cost.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by mruts on Saturday April 27, 2019 @09:19AM (#19765341)
Have you considered that no one wants to open a local shop in the first place? Chains are the only people in the position to take on the huge huge risk of opening a store.

As a store owner, you have exposure to wage laws, property values, foot traffic, etc.

I would personally argue that you would have to irrational to open a mom-and-pop store in this day and age.

Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by dilyevsky on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:15PM (#19759090)
it works because prop 13 (i’m guessing)
Re:“Let's bring a goddamn bookstore to the Bronx.” by bluGill on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:43PM (#19759386)
Prop 13 is in California, this story is about New York.