Re:Potato farmers cry foul as PepsiCo sues them
by ASalazarMX on Thursday April 25, 2019 @01:49PM
(#19750686)
Patentable crops are a recent aberration, selective breeding has worked quite well without patents for millenniums.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Potato farmers cry foul as PepsiCo sues them
by Turing_Machine on Saturday April 27, 2019 @10:35AM
(#19765736)
Throughout most of human history, most populations have faced famine at least one year out of ten, more often in marginal areas (the Israelites planned for one year out of seven, according to the Bible). Sorry, that is not "working quite well" by any reasonable definition.
You really should look into the massive increases in agricultural productivity over the course of the 20th Century before making blanket statements of this nature.
Re:Potato farmers cry foul as PepsiCo sues them
by ASalazarMX on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:41PM
(#19779981)
> You really should look into the massive increases in agricultural productivity over the course of the 20th Century before making blanket statements of this nature.
Way to conflate advances in machinery, irrigation, botany, herbicides and fertilizers in the last century with selective breeding. Take those out and we would have famines now too.
Re:Potato farmers cry foul as PepsiCo sues them
by majewsky on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:43PM
(#19766972)
Most of that is due to industrial-level selective breeding though. (The first commercial GMO was only released in 1994.) So GP's point still stands.
Re:Potato farmers cry foul as PepsiCo sues them
by dragonwriter on Saturday April 27, 2019 @02:52PM
(#19767018)
Modern “Industrial level selective breeding” (which frequently uses a variety of mutagens to maximize the frequency and magnitude of genetic changes to select from) is distinguished from transgenics as a method of inducing genetic change largely by the fact that it's a lot less controlled as to what is going on beyond the targeted trait.
It's kind of odd to scaremonger about organisms whose DNA is a result of transgenic modification but to be okay about those whose DNA is a result of modern industrial selective breeding.