News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CALM Act passed, will quiet loud TV commercials within a ... by _delirium on Monday December 06, 2010 @04:33AM (#1974640)
It's also an example of a market failure where there is no market for the product or service demanded. It's a textbook example of the tragedy of the commons where the gain on the TV signal is owned by no one and thus not protected.

I can buy that it's an example of market failure, but I'm not sure about the second part. According to the idealized free-market theory, this sort of stuff should be taken care of by the market just fine, by people changing the channel away from the objectionable ones, thus commercially penalizing them to the point where running quieter ads becomes the right business decision. That doesn't appear to have happened, probably because while people dislike loud TV ads enough to write to the FCC, they don't dislike them enough to actually meaningfully change their TV-watching habits (so channels with quieter ads don't really gain a commercial advantage).

Re:CALM Act passed, will quiet loud TV commercials within a ... by jackowayed on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:33AM (#1974754)
But it is a market failure. The market for television shows is very far from perfectly competitive.

The products are very differentiated, and there are only a few companies providing the products. But the differentiation is really what matters in this case.

As much as everyone hates loud commercials, channels can't actually gain significant viewership by quieting them down--no one is going to watch a drama with quiet commercials when they really want to be watching the football game with loud commercials.

This means that there's no incentive for a channel to piss off their advertisers by doing this on their own.

This is what governments are for--mandating the socially optimal strategy when the dominant strategy is something else.

Re:CALM Act passed, will quiet loud TV commercials within a ... by jerf on Monday December 06, 2010 @10:47AM (#1975511)
Actually, I don't think that's the source of the market failure. The source of the market failure is that there is no real feedback to the advertisers when the recipients are disgruntled or annoyed. The only people that matter are the Nielson raters, and I don't think there's a slot on their forms for being annoyed by volume. If advertisers saw a big dip every time the commercials came on, and could ask the customers why, and then could run an experiment with more level volume and find out people don't tune out so quickly, they could learn and the market could correct, but due to the nature of the technology not a single step of the requisite path actually existed 20 years ago, and still mostly not today.
Re:CALM Act passed, will quiet loud TV commercials within a ... by loewenskind on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:40AM (#1974848)
>According to the idealized free-market theory

Calling this a "theory" is giving it more credit than is warranted. It's largely an experienced opinion and the only kind of falsification you can do on it is see if implementing parts of it cause society to implode.

Re:CALM Act passed, will quiet loud TV commercials within a ... by shasta on Monday December 06, 2010 @09:44AM (#1975275)
The term "idealized free-market theory" refers to the study of a mathematical model, much like "group theory" refers to the study of groups. It's not a falsible scientific theory that asserts that the model matches reality to any extent.