Re:Laboratory Notebook Skills [pdf]
by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @06:45PM
(#19743289)
Everyone's focusing on charts and notebook types; I'd like to highlight something I find particularly important: reporting uncertainties. I strongly agree with recommendations in this article, and personally I don't think a work qualifies as professional if it reports measurements without providing uncertainties. And no, I don't trust it's correctly rounded off (no more digits than justified by certainty level) - too many people don't care or know they should care, and too many areas of endeavor are poisoned by marketing.
A trivial every-day example of why that matters: a person steps on scales twice in a span of few days, and notices 1 kg of gain, and panics. The reaction is completely unwarranted, given that a cheap household electronic scale will be accurate to +/- 0.5kg in this range, and random daily variability of weight is somewhere around +/- 2 kg. They may as well have lost their average weight over that span, but it's hidden under random and systemic errors.
A trivial every-day example of why that matters: a person steps on scales twice in a span of few days, and notices 1 kg of gain, and panics. The reaction is completely unwarranted, given that a cheap household electronic scale will be accurate to +/- 0.5kg in this range, and random daily variability of weight is somewhere around +/- 2 kg. They may as well have lost their average weight over that span, but it's hidden under random and systemic errors.