News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by tptacek on Monday December 06, 2010 @01:35AM (#1974242)
Amazon never once mentioned copyright. (Please, help yourself to the last word.)
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by michaelkeenan on Monday December 06, 2010 @03:05AM (#1974437)
Humans generally argue to seek truth or status or both. It's a disaster that status-seeking gets involved in the process of truth-seeking, and I wish that we all would recognize that and avoid it when we can (to the extent that we can). "Please, help yourself to the last word" strikes me as motivated by status competition.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by tptacek on Monday December 06, 2010 @11:33AM (#1975718)
It's not.

Try taking the words at their face value, instead. The motivation is avoiding another 20-comment thread that spends 70% of its time dancing around the subtext of one commenter liking WL and the other commenter not liking WL.

Try what Wikipedia tries to do: Assume Good Faith. There are people on HN I, too, have a hard time doing that with, so if you're not assuming good faith because of a 'tptacek issue, please feel free to email me about it.

Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by haploid on Monday December 06, 2010 @01:51AM (#1974282)
Pedantry doesn't suit this discussion well. You are correct that the word copyright was not specified. What was specified was that they hosted content they do not own.

By this standard, I fully expect AWS to terminate services to EVERY SINGLE forum, review site, message board, webmail service, and any other site that does not explicitly state in their own terms of service that every byte of user-generated content is the exclusive property of the site itself.

In addition, I expect any AWS customer hosting IETF RFCs, software with public domain licenses, and public domain poetry to be shut down immediately.

If AWS fails to do this, they are being discriminatory and capricious in pursuing TOS violations.

Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by shard on Monday December 06, 2010 @04:58AM (#1974683)
Your reply seems pedantic as well. All your examples have implicit or explicit permission from the authors for the sites to post their material, as I'm sure you're well aware of.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS by alextgordon on Monday December 06, 2010 @11:58AM (#1975855)
The agreement states you must "own or otherwise control all rights to the content". Merely having permission to display the content is not sufficient.

If I were to be cynical, I'd say that the purpose of that clause is to allow Amazon to take down any site they want and have a credible excuse. Realistically it's probably just some over-zealous lawyer, but either way it has that very effect (as Amazon has demonstrated).