Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by cma on Monday December 06, 2010 @12:57AM
(#1974130)
A hidden boycott? Doesn't make a lot of sense.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by pyre on Monday December 06, 2010 @01:16AM
(#1974172)
Depends on your aim. If you are voting with your wallet and you want Amazon to know why, then spamming these threads doesn't do a lot of good. If you are boycotting and you want to recruit others to do so, then spamming these treads does do a lot of good (for you, the boycotter), but in the end it is a solicitation.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by cma on Monday December 06, 2010 @02:02AM
(#1974299)
I agree with his "don't spam other threads" (and I think a real spamming would make any boycott less effective); I just don't think the comment amounted to spam (which is subjective of course).
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by TomOfTTB on Monday December 06, 2010 @01:32AM
(#1974229)
You can scream boycott from the top of the highest mountain for all I care. Up vote every item that posts on your boycott. Just don't disrupt every other conversation on HN.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by derefr on Monday December 06, 2010 @02:34AM
(#1974369)
A "conversation" on HN is something with a diagonal shape (a comment replying to a comment replying to a comment, etc.) Adding a comment to something (a post or a comment) that already has other comments doesn't "disrupt" the conversation, it branches it. This isn't a phpBB.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by jasonkester on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:01AM
(#1974687)
I think you're mistaken. In this discussion, I actually found it quite disruptive to have to scroll past 60 comments talking about politics so that I could find the discussion about the thing we're actually here to discuss.
They have lots of places on the internet to talk about politics. If you want to do so, I bet you'll have no problem finding an appropriate place.
This, however, is not that place.
Re:Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
by derefr on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:22AM
(#1974727)
There's only the one thread, with those 60 comments in it—so that's really just an artifact of the fact that comment threads can't be collapsed on HN like they can on Reddit. With that addition, this system really does support as many tangents as the userbase cares to follow for any given post, without any egregious annoyance per user, up to a certain scale.
Past that scale (probably 1000 individual threads or so; rarely seen on Reddit, and never on HN), a secondary voting mechanism purely to sort threads by "on-topic-ness" might be required, or perhas an automatic sort on how similar in word usage the comments are to their parent, to derive some crude sense of topicality.