News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Face-Recognition Blamed by New York Teen for False ... by dngray on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:38AM (#19727215)
> But AFAICT from the bloomberg article, at least (I won't go through the Oath hoops to read engadget),

I didn't need to allow oath that to read that. I have my browser configured like so https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix/wiki/How-to-block-1st-par...

For that page all I had was: https://i.imgur.com/DQe8TIr.png you can clearly see oath was not enabled.

It would appear you do need to allow 1st-party JavaScript to allow the <script type="application/ld+json"> portion to load which contains the "articleBody": ....."

I am connected through my VPN, currently in NL, so yeah, GDPR.

Re:Apple Face-Recognition Blamed by New York Teen for False ... by jfk13 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:17AM (#19727420)
Sure, I know there are ways I could work around it. But I shouldn't have to. It's supposed to be easy for a visitor to refuse consent for all that unnecessary tracking - which has no justification in terms of legitimate interest for the purpose of publishing a news article. It shouldn't require technical countermeasures (that 99% of users will not understand).

If they don't offer an opt-out that is as easy as opt-in, I'm going to assume malign intent on the part of the site, and they can do without my traffic.

Re:Apple Face-Recognition Blamed by New York Teen for False ... by dngray on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:27AM (#19727885)
My point is that if you don't allow, the two requests, the page still loads and you don't have to answer any questions.

  www.engadget.com  --  script  https://consent.cmp.oath.com/cmp.js  3p
  www.engadget.com  --  script  https://consent.cmp.oath.com/cmpStub.min.js  3p
> Sure, I know there are ways I could work around it. But I shouldn't have to.

Sadly that's the world we live in.

> It's supposed to be easy for a visitor to refuse consent for all that unnecessary tracking - which has no justification in terms of legitimate interest for the purpose of publishing a news article. It shouldn't require technical countermeasures (that 99% of users will not understand).

It shouldn't yet, it does .

> If they don't offer an opt-out that is as easy as opt-in, I'm going to assume malign intent on the part of the site, and they can do without my traffic.

With media that's a pretty safe assumption.