I'm not entirely sure what I think about that. On the one hand, it seems bad, that instead of having the freedom to exercise situation-specific judgment, doctors are increasingly being pressured to follow predefined flow charts and rubrics, turning it into a sort of cookie-cutter medicine. On the other hand, the statistical evidence in some cases is actually pretty good: for at least a few kinds of things that have been tested, doctors who mindlessly follow a validated process have, on average, better outcomes than the more traditional approach. One explanation that's been advanced for that is that humans are not very good at conditional probabilities, so doctors often make intuitive decisions that, if you run the numbers, aren't statistically the best choice, based on available data. If so, they're better off strictly following a data-derived procedure rather than trying to improvise.
It's a lot worse than pacemakers. Desktop medical image viewing software is also regulated under FDA-510k procedures. Our iPhone viewer has been tied up in the FDA morass for more than two years now. We're submitting a 510k for our cloud image sharing service, just in case.
Basically, if you market your product with the intent for it to be in any way involved with medical procedures, you fall under the purview of the FDA. Which is much, much harder to deal with than the iso equivalents. To the extent that we, as a small american company, have been launching things first in europe.
The idea was that eventually the software, and the equipment, would be released in the USA. This never happened. It is in use in the UK, but bringing into the US would require far more of an up front investment than anyone is willing to make.
In theory, the FDA exists to keep Americans safe. However, it is possible to look at some of its regulatory moves as aiming at consolidation within the industries that supply drugs and equipment to the medical field. I imagine it is easier to regulate an industry with 10 companies than an industry with 10,000 companies. However, the true cost is that a lot of innovation gets squeezed out.
[1] http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed/deaths.htm
"Everything about us was different, and we were naturally resented. While the neighbouring [sic] adults never confronted my father, their children were delighted to bully his children. My siblings and myself became social half-castes, accepted by no class and despised by all. The result in my case was an initial bitter resentment of my community, along with the traditional notions that I should pursue a university education then a career; so I dropped out of school to take a job as a bus conductor...
With determination, skill and a little luck I forged a career in computers before being forced into retirement in 1991...
Of course I could have restarted the education that I abandoned in my teens, but by then the true nature of universities had become obvious; they were no longer centres of learning pursuing truth but centres of profit pursuing customers. Inevitably striving for popularity with youth has made universities bastions of Political Correctness, and full of the kind of people who wanted to burn Galileo for daring to question that the sun circled the earth. So I spent my enforced idleness applying the skills acquired as a system's analyst to discover why my society is disintegrating into delusion and impotence...
In January 2000 I became an Internet publisher, placing a variety of books 'online' at my own expense, in an attempt to preserve some of the vanishing wisdom of humanity...
Indeed I am the first philosopher to realise that philosophy is the study of understanding."
Hmmm...
Weingart SN, Ship AN, Aronson MD (2000). "Confidential clinician-reported surveillance of adverse events among medical inpatients". J Gen Intern Med 15 (7): 470–7. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1495482/?tool=pm...
The "as many as 18%", "admitted to hospitals" and "Iatrogenic injuries" bits make this article say something dramatically different than "1 in 3 of all Americans (not just those hospitalized) die because of an error made by a physician".
Even still that doesn't have much relevance to the 1 in 3 claim, because most people go to the doctors more than once in their life.
Again, no offense - please feel free to quote the JAMA article itself that supports this. Atkinson does a bit more than simply cite actual journal articles, he's taking, to put it lightly, some liberties with information he compiles and personally interprets at will.
Not really because because most people only die after 4 or 5 things go wrong, which means that the causes of death sum to way over 100. E.g. close to 1 in 3 Americans die from drug use, and 7 out of 10 Americans die from chronic illness. But the way it works is that first someone will start smoking (drug use), which then causes chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (chronic illness), and then they will go to the hospital get MRSA because the doctor didn't wash his hands (iatrogenic death).
In Malcolm Gladwell's book Outliers there is a whole chapter on planes that is actually very similar, in that usually 4 or 5 small mistakes have to be made to actually cause a crash.
Now, there are two caveats, other than the (necessarily) very rough nature of the above calculation. First, you may believe that some of the other categories in that row are also things that would be reduced by reducing doctor independence. "Unnecessary procedures" seems like a reasonable candidate for this, though I would assume that since Medical Error is its own category that it tries to be fairly inclusive. Second, you may believe a different number for medical error itself:
"We could have an even higher death rate by using Dr. Lucien Leape's 1997 medical and drug error rate of 3 million. (14) Multiplied by the fatality rate of 14 percent (that Leape used in 1994 (16) we arrive at an annual death rate of 420,000 for drug errors and medical errors combined. If we put this number in place of Lazorou's 106,000 drug errors and the Institute of Medicine's (IOM) 98,000 medical errors, we could add another 216,000 deaths making a total of 999,936 deaths annually."
Side note: Is it just me, or does the author sound hopeful that we might be able to add to the death toll?
If you believe that 420,000 number (about 4x higher than what's in the table), that'd be about 10%.
Did you get "1 in 3" by attributing all iatrogenic deaths to doctor error?
Yes, because despite the fact that there is a category called medical errors, almost all of the other deaths listed are medical errors as well. It's not like there is really any legitimate reason for more than a trivial amount of people to get MRSA in a hospital seeing as when best practices are followed the rate of line infections goes from 4% to 0%.
"How do you figure, even assuming these figures are (still) accurate (many of them are 10-20 years old)?"
The NY Times just published an article a week ago saying the rate of medical errors hasn't gotten any better, which I linked to below.
This thread was originally about decision-making power being shifted from doctors (M.D.s) to insurance companies, administrators, regulators, laywers, and even patients themselves. Your first comment suggested that this is a good thing because those same M.D.s kill 1/3 of all Americans (and as a corollary, the other parties involved plus the other healthcare providers that outnumber M.D.s many-to-one kill nobody).
I think it's pretty suspect that the linked page cherry-picks its numbers, rather than trying to assemble them all from a single source which has taken some care not to double-count. Granted, such a source may not exist, but essentially the death toll for each cause X is taken from a paper which is trying to make a big deal out of X.
The fact that those numbers sound fishy is orthogonal to the fact that I don't think they would be any better if the power to make treatment decisions is taken from those best equipped to make it.
And all of that is orthogonal to the fact that the linked page does not even attempt to show this, so it doesn't really seem to support the point you were making with that citation.
1.) The FDA is imposing stricter limits on how doctors prescribe.
2.) The insurance companies are imposing limits on what doctors can do.
The trend has been developing for several decades, but it only came into clear focus during the 1990s, when the HMOs first gained prominence. Doctors have lost a great deal of independence compared to what they had 100 years ago, or even 50 years ago.
#1 has at least 2 parts:
a.) The War On Drugs: this has lead to limits on how aggressively doctors can manage pain. Too aggressive and the doctor comes under scrutiny.
b.) The widening powers of the FDA. Over the last 50 years the FDA has become a general clearing house for all new technologies that effect health. Whereas its focus was once on drugs, it now has substantial say over every kind of medial procedure, including such things as pacemakers.
A simple model of the contending forces might include these main actors:
1.) patients
2.) doctors
3.) government
4.) hospitals
5.) patient insurance companies
6.) doctor liability insurance companies
A simple model would simply assert that each of these is trying to lower their risk, partly by moving the risk onto one of the other players. (A more complicated model would have trial lawyers as their own element, but here the trial lawyers are assumed to be part of #1). In a simple model, you could assert:
risk = the power to make decisions
The more each group tries to get rid of its own risk, the more it also loses the power to make its own decisions. This is a simple model, but it clearly has some truth.
What we've also seen in the last few decades is that when risk in the system goes beyond what private sector actors can manage, then the risk, and the decision making, gets taken over by the government. This was a long term trend, but the trend was made very explicit and visible during the crisis of 2008/2009, when lots of private sector actors failed (Lehman, General Motors, etc) and were taken over by the government.
I keep looking for some sign that this trend might abate, but for now, it seems likely to continue, if in modified form.
Conclusions?
You can become a doctor. You will be respected. You will be well paid. You will lack the independence that has been traditionally associated with the role. But despite that, you may enjoy the work.