And illegal in California as of last year. Hopefully them forcing companies to allow online cancellations will mean it's available for the rest of us too.
https://www.cnet.com/news/companies-must-let-customers-cance...
My ex-employer was surprised that when they were obliged by law to stop routing everybody though a retention call center customer satisfaction improved. Too much of their own Kool Aid had been drunk, they'd persuaded themselves that customers wanted to be reminded of the benefits and offered other deals by a human so much that they'd hate even having the option to just press "Cancel" on the web site and leave that way.
It's an old Joel Spoelsky lesson, if you make leaving a pleasant experience that customer may come back some day. If not you're never going to see them again.
I've just decided to let the customer pre-pay for up to the limit I'm willing to guarantee that I'll keep running the service, even at a loss (two years at the moment). I figure if the service isn't worth a user's time to click once to re-subscribe every few years, then I probably shouldn't be taking their money.
I admit this might be a bit naive from a business perspective :)
The first is used for re-occuring bills (Netflix, Phone, internet etc).
The second is for everyday spending (Amazon, groceries, sundries etc). The second has an extremely low threshhold for alerts and emails about pretty much every transaction.
If something were to set itself to autopay, I'd notice very quickly since card 1 pings me, and card 2 only should have <10 merchants per month for easy auditing.
(Paying in cash for entertainment expenses also makes auditing easier. Having every cup of coffee or burrito clogging your statement makes it hard to spot double charges and other small frauds)
The existence of this pattern is the sole reason why I'm using PayPal.
Now with this organization, you can donate via the website but to cancel a recurring donation requires a phone call. I called a couple of times to try to cancel but didn't reach anybody. I admit- I wasn't too concerned (a good organization overall), but I was a little pissed nevertheless.
My credit card was skimmed, and I had it cut off. I figured this would solve my problem with the donations as well. Nope.
About two years later my wife (who actually handles the bills in the family) asked me if I wanted to continue those payments. I was pretty shocked- and persisted with the phone calls until I reached somebody to cancel.
Surprise!
I consider the "signing up can be done on the web, but canceling requires a human" to be a dark pattern.