News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by dangus on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:48AM (#19716606)
Works fine for me incognito with ads and tracker blocking extensions enabled.

Keep in mind that the journalist who did the research and wrote the article did not have a say in how the employer who enabled them to write this piece generates revenue.

Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by linuxasheviller on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:30AM (#19719651)
> Keep in mind that the journalist who did the research and wrote the article did not have a say in how the employer who enabled them to write this piece generates revenue.

In a way, she did. She is not an NYT employee, but rather, a professor at UNC Chapel Hill who could have published this piece elsewhere.

To be clear, I don't fault her for her choice at all. Just pointing out that we all "opt-in" to this system when we participate in it, and that's a part of the problem.

Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by dangus on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:09PM (#19720077)
I do agree with you, though I think opting out of the practices of most websites is impractical. The utility of my usage of the Internet far outweighs some advertisers figuring out what I like to buy. We do need more robust advertising privacy laws, though.

By not being a NYT employee she has even less of a say in the matter. I'm sure she knows that nobody's going to read her article if it's published in The Daily Tar Heel.

If someone gave you the opportunity to publish an article in The New York Times would you say no?

I should also point out that the print edition of the NYT is still widely circulated, and it seems this article would have appeared in the Opinion section, tracker free :-)

Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by ricardobeat on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:42PM (#19720375)
This is taking a bit too far, but if someone offered you a fully-paid trip to the Caribbean* would you say no?

* with money from dubious origin

Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by Bartweiss on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:27PM (#19720225)
> Just pointing out that we all "opt-in" to this system when we participate in it, and that's a part of the problem.

This really is a significant point.

All-visitor paywalls already crumbled, and a few of the worst excesses of tracking at least getting debated, so this is a place where users can get actual traction. It's the same sort of collective action problem as voting, true; writers and publishers have far more influence than any given reader. But it's also true that the space is far more open than voting.

There are a lot of news sites (e.g. The Boston Globe) which have shut out incognito access, filled their sites with trackers, and loaded up on dark patterns to push people towards misleadingly-priced subscriptions. And for almost everything they publish, there's minimal cost to just... not reading it. If it's a major story, it will be covered elsewhere. I know I'm not changing the world when I skip their links, but I'm protecting a bit of my own data, and putting a bit of pressure on them to do better.

Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by wgj on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:42AM (#19719766)
NYT is still A/B testing this feature. It appears to be enabled an increasingly higher percentage of page loads over the past few weeks.
Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by gatherhunterer on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:56PM (#19735159)
Incognito does not prevent Google from tracking you. They claim that they do not but it is not a standard for private browsing.
Re:Think You’re Discreet Online? Think Again by idlewords on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:54PM (#19721036)
This is an opinion piece, not an article. Zeynep Tufekci is a professor at UNC and does not work for the New York Times.