News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Planting 1.2T Trees Could Cancel Out a Decade of CO2 Emis... by _ph_ on Sunday April 21, 2019 @05:27PM (#19714682)
The current vegetation is adapted well to the CO2 levels before industrialisation, that is about 300ppm CO2. The change in CO2-content is actually detrimental to some plants. Furthermore, the quick temperature change is going to wipe out large eco systems. The question isn't, what is the optimal CO2 concentration for single species, but about the health of the eco systems we are living in. We are about to wipe out large eco systems and as a consequence, the environment we are living in.
Re:Planting 1.2T Trees Could Cancel Out a Decade of CO2 Emis... by Radim on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:36AM (#19717201)
I actually agree with you.

Perhaps the confusion stems from my too-vague use of "we". Your "we" (understandably) refers to humans, who indeed stand much to lose by dramatic CO₂ swings. At least on a suitably mayfly time scale.

My "we" meant more "life on this planet", without as much anthropomorphic bias. Periods of increased warmth and easy access to carbon — the two are historically highly correlated, though not synonymous — are an overall boon to life, referred to as "warm periods", "climatic optimums", "life explosions", etc. This despite the ecosystem upheavals that accompany such large-scale climatic changes being detrimental to incumbent organisms. No argument there.

Coupled with the polarized political nature of the topic, I suspect this difference in "we" resulted in people reading too much into my comment, if you take the time to re-read it. My stance on short-term human-centric status-quo-preserving actions is probably not that different from yours, although I do find broader perspectives and facts helpful in framing rational discourse.

Re:Planting 1.2T Trees Could Cancel Out a Decade of CO2 Emis... by _ph_ on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:38AM (#19719734)
The topic of the article discussed is an approach reducing the CO2 in the atmosphere, to fight the current and ongoing climate change. This sets the context for the discussion. Yes, in geological times, we had much higher CO2-content and some of the plants are still rather optimized for that. This is interesting information, but is an entirely different topic - though it is an argument often used to deny the harmful impact of CO2 onto the climate.

Also, the sole concern of the human species is the survival of the species. Of course we should try to ensure this survival in the most ethical way. Protecting the environment comes from those concerns. Climate change is a very big danger to our civilisation right now.