News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first serious infowar is now engaged by kragen on Sunday December 05, 2010 @03:54AM (#1971260)
Your statement is completely wrong, from beginning to end.

(I am going to do my readers the honor of assuming they know what a public good is. If not, I suggest they look it up.)

Science is a public good. Lots of science is funded by governments, but lots of science is done without government funding, too.

Recorded music and books are now public goods, now that it is so cheap to copy them and to find instances to copy. Only a small fraction of them are provided by governments. Many of them are provided by individuals rather than institutions of any kind.

TV and radio broadcasts are a public good. In some countries, they are mostly provided by governments, but in almost all countries, they are at least partly provided by private parties who fund them with advertising. In the US, many "public TV stations" are actually funded mostly by public subscription, using "pledge drives" in which viewers receive an item of nominal value in exchange for pledging to donate to the station if enough other people do so; this is a variety of the dominant assurance contract.

Views of fireworks that go more than a few meters high are a public good. Here in Buenos Aires, they are provided almost exclusively by private individuals. At Christmas and New Year's, the sky over the entire city is filled with amazing displays. In countries with less freedom, such displays are sometimes provided exclusively by governments, but that is far from invariable.

Lighthouses were public goods. Palacio Barolo, the lighthouse six blocks from my house, is now only operational as a lighthouse one night a month, and in any case it's been obsoleted by radio systems and impeded by the building of other, taller buildings between it and the river, but it was constructed by a wealthy businessman.

Many public goods, including TV broadcasts, lighthouses, views of fireworks, and recorded music, are definitely not needed.

In conclusion, you don't need anybody to provide public goods; entities that are not institutions often provide public goods; many public goods can be provided worldwide, rather than within particular regions; even in cases where public goods are provided by institutions, the institutions are often not governments or government-supported; and even in cases where public goods are provided by governments, those same public goods are also often provided by non-government institutions as well.

I am not taking any position here on whether or not governments are necessary.

There are no comments on this comment yet.