Gain control of a bunch of sites that are hosting viruses, autodownloading exe's, or otherwise performing unlawful hacks on the user. Then start linking to all of the people who rank higher than you. You could pick off all of your pagerank competitors one by one.
(this is theoretical, but I don't see why it wouldn't work in a probabilistic sense)
The'll say a competitor bought the links to their website, then reported them to Google for black-hat SEO -- basically setting them up and then turning them in. Of course, this is the first defense anyone would use if they were caught actually link spamming -- so who can tell how common it is. (By the way, I don't see how Google could tell either.)
There are rumors of other bad things going on too. People duplicating your content to try and get your copy removed, bogus DMCA claims, etc.
It is easy to forget that Google is not the Internet. A time goes on, SEO will cause Google to become nearly useless, and people will move onto greener pastures.
Where YOU link has an effect on your ranking, but surely not who links TO you.
Right?