News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by tocomment on Saturday December 04, 2010 @10:52PM (#1970984)
Is PRK better?
Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by lockem on Sunday December 05, 2010 @02:36AM (#1971195)
The difference between PRK and Lasik is in the way they reshape your cornea.

In Lasik they create a flap by cutting the cornea and then they use a laser to reshape it, then they reposition the flap back in place.This way the flap acts as a bandage on the wound and reconnects with the cornea. The Flap is never actually healed and may be dislodged even years after the surgery - Although will need significant force like a direct poke in the eye, severe car accident etc.

In PRK a flap isn't created, the laser reshapes the cornea directly (After removing a small epithelial layer) and then a special bandage contact lens is applied to the wound. This is generally considered safer (Nothing to be dislodged), But the healing process is much slower and the time it takes until your eyes are at their best capacity is much longer. As i previously wrote, I was back at work the next day and my sight was almost perfect after 3 days. My cousin had PRK, the total healing time was around 2-3 weeks, and in the first week she could barely open her eyes.

PRK is also considered a little less accurate, but i am not sure why... For a nice comparison see: http://www.lasereyefacts.com/prk-vs-lasik.html

Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by mdaniel on Sunday December 05, 2010 @07:04AM (#1971480)
I also chose PRK because I was uncomfortable with the flap, and was willing to risk the painful (and slower) healing process.

While I am not your scenario with the 3 days, I would say that one week is a proper expectation, with some deviation one way or the other.

The pain (in case no one has mentioned it) is very much like leaving a contact in for too long: it feels like your eyeball has been packed in salt. I mean that in both the extreme dehydration sense, and it occasionally actually feels like salt in your eyes.

I had a few instances where it felt like needles in my eyes, and that was my only need to use the prescribed pain medicine. It lasted until I fell asleep from the pain pills.

I do hope this doesn't come across as a horror story: I absolutely, with no hesitation at all, would do it again and would use the same doctor. I am _extremely_ happy, and sing the praises, but wanted to ensure it is an informed decision for those who might be weighing the pros and cons.

Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by pingswept on Sunday December 05, 2010 @01:09AM (#1971137)
Sorry, but I have no expertise to comment on that.
Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by mdaniel on Sunday December 05, 2010 @07:06AM (#1971487)
"Better" is always a tricky word.

I think that it is likely a matter of what aspects are important to you (aside from those patients who are forced into using, or excluded from using, one technology or the other).

I received a comprehensive description from my doctor, and chose PRK because I was not comfortable with "the flap," and I was comfortable that there would be some pain and longer healing time. That was my tradeoff, and I am thrilled with how it turned out.

Re:Ask HN: experiences with Lasik eye surgery (programmers e... by huhtenberg on Sunday December 05, 2010 @01:21AM (#1971149)
From what I understand talking to an ophthalmologist it's either PRK or Lasik. One of these is always a better fit for a specific patient.