News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by frankbreetz on Saturday April 20, 2019 @05:54PM (#19709100)
I guess, you have to answer the question as to how the 1% earned it. If they started on a level playing field and just worked harder or were smarter than everyone else, I would say keep it. More likely though it was passed down for generations and they did nothing to deserve it, I find that situation absolutely insane. We found out in the great depression having an insanely wealthy class of people (Rockafellers,Gatsbys, Vanderbilts... )is not good for society.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by crispinb on Saturday April 20, 2019 @06:39PM (#19709352)
I did an economic history lit survey back in the '80s (lost now unfortunately) which showed that a very substantial portion of UK wealth at that time had a direct lineage back to slavery on sugar plantations. Even if you judge that meritocracy works justly within a generation, without appropriate taxation wealth accumulates over time, often consequent on terrible injustices. It takes some pretty heroic ethical gymnastics to justify that let alone consider it efficient or useful.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by village-idiot on Saturday April 20, 2019 @06:06PM (#19709191)
Also, most of their ancestors got it via force. William the Conqueror wasn’t exactly a super civil dude.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday April 20, 2019 @10:03PM (#19710128)
You do realize that Gatsby was fictional, don't you? Adding him to your list does not make your case stronger...
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by gbacon on Saturday April 20, 2019 @08:27PM (#19709776)
You did nothing to deserve winning multiple genetic lotteries, namely having sufficient intelligence to fall into the HN cohort and being born into a wealthy country and household with access to it and similar resources. You didn’t earn your spot in the global 1%, but it in no way follows that you should be expropriated to correct the alleged injustice.

Ex post facto law has since the Enlightenment recognized as unjust and even tyrannical. Digging back across generations in search of some offense generations ago and punishing innocent parties today is at best a recipe for chaos.

Lavrentiy Beria was head of Stalin’s secret police and famous for saying, “Show me the man, and I’ll show you the crime.” Expropriating present people because of unfair advantages — a criterion never precisely defined and forever subject to political fads of the day, which is to say meaningless — allegedly enjoyed by past ancestors or owners of property is merely another form of the Beria method.

By your own reasoning, neither did the state today do anything to deserve the property that they’d seize. Even if it were justly redistributed, you’re forgetting about the cut taken by the middlemen in charge of carrying it out — who also did nothing to deserve taking a share of the loot.

No sound economic case can be made that the distribution of wealth was a cause for the Great Depression. Considering how many human abilities have normal and power-law distributions, e.g., attractiveness, musical ability, intelligence, vertical leap, height, programming skill, lifetime poker winnings, writing quality, golf handicap, typing speed, cooking skill, time to change a tire, ability to plan and manage complex tasks, future orientation, etc., etc., etc., income and wealth accumulation being anywhere remotely uniform would be amazing. Considering the math of power-law distributions, your approach would have a huge majority ganging up on a comparatively tiny minority but ironically in the name of fairness.

“No legal plunder; this is the principle of justice, peace, order, stability, harmony and logic.”

Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by claudiawerner on Sunday April 21, 2019 @11:25AM (#19712481)
>Ex post facto law has since the Enlightenment recognized as unjust and even tyrannical. Digging back across generations in search of some offense generations ago and punishing innocent parties today is at best a recipe for chaos.

That's not what's going on here at all. The idea is that property gained through unjust means originally means that the wealth derived from it is still unjustly derived, even if this unjust appropriation happened long ago when it was not deemed unjust then. You would be right if the case were if you were to be punished for the fact your ancestors owned slaves, but the issue is the benefit gained which is currently there.

>income and wealth accumulation being anywhere remotely uniform would be amazing.

Nobody is saying it would be uniform, they're saying that the situation at the moment is not due to the difference in those abilities other than perhaps brute strength in subjugation and plunder. It is difficult to imagine what the world would look like if it hadn't happened, but the distribution of wealth would not be as we see it today in any case.

>By your own reasoning, neither did the state today do anything to deserve the property that they’d seize.

The state may act on behalf of those at a comparative disadvantage, and we have an easier case for arguing they deserve something.

Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by frankbreetz on Saturday April 20, 2019 @09:36PM (#19710031)
I feel like "people who won the genetic lottery" who become rich,by inventing something or creating something, deserve it because ideally these people made money by improving society and this behavior should be encouraged. I understand this is not how the world always works, but it should be the world we strive for.

In my mind this would be the ideal role of government to encourage behavior that makes society better.

[dead]
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by frankbreetz on Saturday April 20, 2019 @07:07PM (#19709494)
As far as I know, The current rule in the US is inheritance tax doesn't apply to the first 5 million. This seems to be more than fair.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 21, 2019 @02:23AM (#19710807)
I can't understand what you're trying to say in your penultimate sentence. 'Property is theft' was Proudhon, not Marx.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by int_19h on Sunday April 21, 2019 @12:02AM (#19710472)
It depends on which Marxists. Some would say that land that your family can cultivate (or otherwise productively use) on your own, without hiring labor, is your personal property, which is not theft. Land that you own, but can't extract wealth from it without hiring other people to do so (and collecting rent from what they extract from it) would be considered theft.
Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by sonnyblarney on Saturday April 20, 2019 @06:31PM (#19709306)
"More likely though it was passed down for generations and they did nothing to deserve it, I find that situation absolutely insane"

It's not insane for people to pass their property from one person to another.

Arbitrary definitions of 'earned it' are far, far scarier.

Surely, it's important to consider issues such as private wealth, inheritance etc. but the OP is effectively correct, this issue turns into 'mob rule' very, very quickly.

In 2019 we forget this, because we don't have any such topsy-turvy situations in living memory, but the 19th and 20th centuries were full of blood and fury over this kind of stuff.

Everywhere East of Berlin does however have this in 'living memory'. Ask a Polish, Ukrainian, Czech, Russian etc. immigrant over the age of 60 about it for an earful. Or someone Chinese over 60 as well. Or Cuban.

'Private Property' is a very, very careful issue.

Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by int_19h on Sunday April 21, 2019 @12:00AM (#19710467)
I think most would agree that property that was stolen or taken by force from somebody who produced it, is not earned. So it's not an arbitrary definition. And if that is so, why would passing it from generation to generation make any difference to that determination?

I am a Russian immigrant, by the way, born in the USSR back when it was still a thing. I don't have much sympathy for the kind of wealth redistribution that was practiced there. But it's important to understand that the reason why it happened was because inequality was allowed to grow high enough that a sufficient number of people in the country could be motivated to revolt, because they felt the risks justified the potential rewards. And it doesn't even matter if they were right or wrong - the point is, if you are afraid of that history repeating, then you should support measures that prevent the conditions that caused it from happening again. And that involves acknowledging what the society deems fair and unfair, when it comes to property ownership.

Re:Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Populatio... by sonnyblarney on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:29AM (#19711593)
1) Applying notions of ownership to systems 1000 years ago - is totally arbitrary.

2) The Sovereign's holding are, and always have been something different than a regular person's holdings. They have always beens somewhat matters of State.

3) Today, the monarchies are constitutional. They do not 'own' the land as you and I would 'own' land.

4) Most wealthy people today did not inherit their land from people 100's of years ago who got it from plunder - this is ridiculous. About 1/2 of the wealthy people today are 'self made'.

5) Almost everyone in modern civilization has access to opportunity, and as you'll notice from this thread, 90% of Canadian land holding for example is by the government, i.e. commons - there is plenty of land and resources to go around. Everyone can participate.

Inequality today is not even comparable to what is is even 100 years ago. People receive free healthcare, almost free banking services, cheap water, cheap transport, cheap entertainment, cheap clothing, cheap access to information, free social solidarity.