News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by stickfigure on Saturday April 20, 2019 @05:06PM (#19708881)
Because it creates an information asymmetry. They now know what you (are willing to) work for, but you don't know what they're willing to pay, or what everyone else in the company makes.

It does not benefit you to disclose the information, even if you think your number is high. They might assume you are lying, or they might already be anchored at an even higher number - you don't know.

Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by m463 on Saturday April 20, 2019 @06:38PM (#19709344)
I kind of wonder about these things, but I'm not in sales.

I've heard two stories about car dealers that each say different things.

One story was about a car dealer that told its salesmen the actual wholesale price of the cars they were selling. The salesmen would deal from that price upwards and would always sell the cars close to that price. They changed to only telling them the retail price of the car and then sales from that point on were much higher as the selling prices clustered nearer to retail.

But the other story was from a friend who used to work at a car dealer. The top sales guy would move an enormous number of cars. He would sell them for $250 over invoice. My friend said he was amazing, and it was common for other salesmen to spend hours haggling with a customer on one car, and meanwhile the top guy would move 4 or 5 cars.

Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by TallGuyShort on Saturday April 20, 2019 @09:52PM (#19710091)
Trouble is you can't sell yourself 4-5x as often as a total job length without that starting to reflect poorly on you. You don't get paid per job. Maybe a valuable lesson for contractors, though: there's value in simplicity if it leads to volume.
Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by ianai on Saturday April 20, 2019 @05:53PM (#19709099)
It’s not a clear cut never do. If you know you’re expecting the higher end of a salary range then it’s absolutely in your interest to signal that from the outset. Telling them your current salary is doing just that.

But otherwise I agree. The company always has such a strong hand that it’s in your best interest to play every one of your cards as strategically, carefully as possible.

Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by petre on Sunday April 21, 2019 @12:06AM (#19710483)
Can't you just tell them not to bother with the interview any further and refrain from wasting everyone's time if they're not prepared to offer what you've asked for?
Re:We Don't Have a Talent Shortage. We Have a Sucker Shortage by teawrecks on Saturday April 20, 2019 @11:54PM (#19710446)
However, not discussing compensation with your peers ONLY benefits the companies you work for. It encourages anti-competative behavior.