Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by HNKingpin on Saturday April 20, 2019 @03:27PM
(#19708414)
You should be able to see the effects, no? At least in cameras (the light won't be flashing).
Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by svrtknst on Sunday April 21, 2019 @09:41AM
(#19712031)
Maybe - Unless the bypass circumvents that. NSA did exactly that on Samsung (Tizen) TVs a few years back.
One of their hacks, IIRC, was that they turned off the standby light so it would appear the TV was shut off.
Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by Nasrudith on Sunday April 21, 2019 @06:53AM
(#19711503)
Well the thing is they are absurdly fine electronics. It is trivial to reroute so that the switch applies to the LED and not the camera itself (and some other trickery based upon reading its state while keeping it covertly operational). Said lie could still be detected in other ways of course but it wouldn't be a simple and complete fix.
Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by NikkiA on Sunday April 21, 2019 @08:23AM
(#19711757)
To be fair, if I wanted to build covert surveillance I could also trivially make the switch appear to turn off the camera to commercial camera software but not actually disconnect from my covert software that I provide to TPTB.
Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by askvictor on Saturday April 20, 2019 @09:02PM
(#19709921)
Microphones are much more the worry; you can't cover them up like a camera, and are omnidirectional.
Re:Vendors must start adding physical on/off switches to dev...
by Scoundreller on Saturday April 20, 2019 @11:54PM
(#19710447)
MacBook airs have tiny holes near the microphone. If it’s plugged, it’s very difficult to hear what’s going on.
Other macs may be like this too.
If I don't trust their software switches, why would I trust their hardware switches?