News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Should you buy a house and rent it out? by zenkat on Saturday April 20, 2019 @10:44AM (#19706765)
Try using the model with a very high down payment. At 50% of property value, your gains are equivalent to the 7% baseline. Beyond that, the property makes significantly less than the stock market. If you pay 100% up front, you end up making half what the stock market does.

In other words, the gains shown by this model are coming from leverage, not from the underlying asset. Leveraged investments always return more, but with higher risk. That's true in the housing market as well as the stock market.

Re:Show HN: Should you buy a house and rent it out? by evancox100 on Saturday April 20, 2019 @11:39AM (#19707094)
Leveraged assets are not necessarily always more risk than unleveraged ones. You also have to look at the underlying risk/volatility.

That said, I agree with your point in this case that the leverage is the main component of the return, and greatly increases "risk", for some definition of that word. In a non-recourse state where you can default on the mortgage without losing other assets, the risk calculation must also take that into account.

Re:Show HN: Should you buy a house and rent it out? by tyxodiwktis on Saturday April 20, 2019 @12:11PM (#19707276)
In addition to your point about leverage and underlying asset volatility, certain assets are not regularly marked to market (real estate being a prime example) and so you don't experience the true volatility of the asset unless you attempt to sell it.

As a concrete example, a number of commercial real estate investors were technically insolvent in 2008-2009, with assets worth less than the balances of the loans used to buy them. They just pursued the 'hear no evil/see no evil/speak no evil' approach and marked to book (what they paid for the asset) until the market recovered. This approach is aided by the multi-year nature of commercial leases, which protects the cash flows needed for debt service (as long as your tenants stay in business).

In aggregate these factors allow professional real estate investors to consistently earn return by taking on a ton of leverage and with it huge but disguised risk. Back to the original point of the article (buying to rent), most retail investors don't necessarily have the float/access to debt to weather that volatility, and their cash flows are more sensitive which compounds that risk.