Re:Ron Paul: ‘What we need is more WikiLeaks’
by tptacek on Saturday December 04, 2010 @06:58PM
(#1970532)
In a similar vein: Daniel Ellsberg knew the contents of the Pentagon Papers and knew exactly what the public interest was in having that particular information leaked. Mark Felt had a thesis about the public benefit in leaking Watergate. Jeffery Wigand knew what and why he was leaking tobacco documents. Mark Klein knew what & why about NSA surveillance. Those were purposeful leaks.
These leaks are indiscriminate. Does anyone believe that Bradley Manning had any idea what he was handing off to WL? Remember, WL themselves claim to have redacted those documents to protect innocents (the belief that they couldn't possibly have done so adequately animates much of the flak they're taking). If WL had to redact them, then the actual leaker (presumed to be Manning) had to have disclosed them unredacted --- to complete strangers.
These leaks are indiscriminate. Does anyone believe that Bradley Manning had any idea what he was handing off to WL? Remember, WL themselves claim to have redacted those documents to protect innocents (the belief that they couldn't possibly have done so adequately animates much of the flak they're taking). If WL had to redact them, then the actual leaker (presumed to be Manning) had to have disclosed them unredacted --- to complete strangers.