Brand. It's why people pay for bottled water vs. free tap water.
It's why Groupon can argue they can send more people to you than their competitors.
Say Groupon offers a 50% off $10 coupon for $5, and keeps the $5. The business is out $10 (for the goods).
Now Soupon (fictitious name) comes along, offers a 60% off $10 coupon for $4; but keeps $2 and gives the business $2. Now the business is out only $8; the customer gets a better discount; and Soupon still makes money.
Don't you think most of Groupon's customers will move to Soupon in a heartbeat?
Groupon is the first tech brand that local merchants have totally bought into. Sure a percentage will be adventurous and go with the cheaper groupon-clone, but the vast majority will stick with the brand name imo.
Groupon has zero barrier to entry and zero technology. Unless they have a strong IP portfolio (which they don't appear to be, given the number of competitors that have sprung up), I don't see the value here, other than brand name.
I was given a Groupon for a local specialty chocolate vendor recently, so I decided to chat her up to see what she felt about it. She had tried Groupon, Townhog and a couple of others. She shrugged and said that she wasn't sure if she was going to try these again; but if she did, she'd use Townhog. It was clear that there was no barrier for her to switch. Why should merchants give Groupon 50% of the face value of coupon, if their competitor will do the same for 25%? And the next one at 10%?