On one hand, it's good to err on the side of too-long a book, as it's easier to skip fluff than to seek out more details, illustrations, and alternative phrasings that aren't in the book. On the other hand, it's annoying to have the extra weight in volume in one's book collection.
The worst is when the first three chapters are about how rich/smart/successful you'll become by reading this book! (Except for the first three chapters, of course, because those are just advertisements for the book you already acquired.)
The one that bothered me the most was the inclusion of the India soap program as support for checklists -- those are entirely different models.
The soap model involved researchers handing out free soap, and teaching people that they should wash with the soap in any of a set of specific circumstances:
- once a day (full body)
- before preparing food (hands)
- before eating (hands)
- before distributing food to anyone (hands)
- after defecating (hands)
- after wiping an infant (hands)
This made a big dent in the prevalence of disease in experimental neighborhoods. Great! This was a good idea. But it's not an example of a checklist. The concept here is that, every time you do anything at all, you see whether it's one of those five hands-washing circumstances, and if it is, then you wash your hands. This is the opposite of a checklist, where you perform a series of verifications whenever you take a specific particular action, not whenever you take any action at all.(Obviously, people can't handle the mental load of "before doing _anything_, check to see..." and instead would have added "wash your hands" to the appropriate five behavioral sequences. That reduces the mental load from (1) a constant mental drain on any activity of any kind to (2) learning five things. But if you make that switch, you stop having any relationship to the checklist concept at all.)
Same author as the book, but earlier. Contains all the meat, but none of the repetitions and the tenuous analogies.
Gawande had enough for a long-form article, but not for a book, and IMO it shows.
The book isn't bad. It's just that the essay is better.