2) I'm pretty sure LinkedIn could have sold for a mighty sum in 2006. My guess is they're pretty nervous that Facebook will subsume them. They might wish they had sold back then for $1 billion or whatever.
3) Very speculative: Xobni, but that was 2008.
4) Technorati may have turned down an offer in late 2005 that they would definitely take today.
I'm not sure these prove anything, I just had fun trying to think of them.
I agree Digg got an offer they probably regret not taking.
If there are more Pointcasts than Facebooks that would infer that it would be statistically more probable for this company to be overvalued than undervalued.
Pointing to outliers and using those as examples of good decisions doesn't seem very wise. Sometimes you get lucky and hit it big, that's how the game works. Sometimes that risk bites you down the road, a la Pointcast.
It's wise if you are an outlier. And Groupon seems to be an outlier to me.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Facebook#Financials