Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb
by roenxi on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @07:15PM
(#19678155)
The incentive structures around US education look perverse and horrible.
Consider the amount of money locked up in the major American institutions [0]. It just seems improbable that the money is going to be well managed in a system where literally sitting around all day talking about philosophy is an accepted, hopefully encouraged, activity. In that environment the words 'well managed' lose all meaning, the only metric is results a generation or two after the fact.
Then there are the people who go into the system; people who reasonably were born into a wealthy family, went through a good educational institute, learned at a good university then spent a great deal of effort pushing thorough to a professorship. There are going to be many individuals who are completely buffered from having real-world experience in an environment where safety is not guaranteed. Furthermore, the population of a university campus is going to have a large portion of clever but underdeveloped and inexperienced students floating around in it.
So there is an environment where the administration has every incentive to become corrupted by money and the faculty have no guide-rails to prevent the formation of really disconnected world views. It is a testimony to the raw drive and intelligence of the people involved that it all hangs together at all.
There are more Americans being processed through environment [1]. Talking about the conditions of the professorship is an important facet, but it is not wise to isolate that from its place in the greater system - the direction is that most people are going to be university educated and the overall system probably doesn't have the sort of governance structure that can cope with this slow influx.
Consider the amount of money locked up in the major American institutions [0]. It just seems improbable that the money is going to be well managed in a system where literally sitting around all day talking about philosophy is an accepted, hopefully encouraged, activity. In that environment the words 'well managed' lose all meaning, the only metric is results a generation or two after the fact.
Then there are the people who go into the system; people who reasonably were born into a wealthy family, went through a good educational institute, learned at a good university then spent a great deal of effort pushing thorough to a professorship. There are going to be many individuals who are completely buffered from having real-world experience in an environment where safety is not guaranteed. Furthermore, the population of a university campus is going to have a large portion of clever but underdeveloped and inexperienced students floating around in it.
So there is an environment where the administration has every incentive to become corrupted by money and the faculty have no guide-rails to prevent the formation of really disconnected world views. It is a testimony to the raw drive and intelligence of the people involved that it all hangs together at all.
There are more Americans being processed through environment [1]. Talking about the conditions of the professorship is an important facet, but it is not wise to isolate that from its place in the greater system - the direction is that most people are going to be university educated and the overall system probably doesn't have the sort of governance structure that can cope with this slow influx.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_colleges_and_universit...
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/184272/educational-attai...