News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ChrisSD on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:35PM (#19675080)
Very off topic, but the backstop is only meant to take effect if no other agreement can be made by the end of the transition period. If it does take effect, it's meant to be temporary until such time as a more permanent deal is agreed (although it's true it could last indefinitely if no such agreement is ever made).
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by mrec on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:40PM (#19675126)
Yes, but the EU has both the ability and every economic incentive to refuse any permanent agreement that doesn't give them at least the same level of UK lock-in. The "temporary" is a figleaf to try to sell the WA to domestic voters and MPs; I don't think anyone takes it seriously.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by pergadad on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:02PM (#19676335)
You're reading too much bad/biased reporting. Anyone who ever worked in international relations or trade knows that the worst case is uncertainty. It's neither in the UK's not in the EU's interest.

It's quite weird to see how much the news and information cycle in the UK is based on rumours and quotes of random MPs. Like, seriously, try to think for a second from the EU's perspective and it's just plain obvious how it's not in the EU's interest to keep the UK in an arrangement that it's uncomfortable with and that has no clear legal standing. Everything gets more costly and complex - think just of external trade negotiations, import taxes, quality standards and norms, etc which all fall into a place of uncertain "could change at any minute" state in such a situation.

The EU is not some weird evil creature.thstsboutnto get you. The EU is the set of countries that for decades have been your closest allies. No one is trying to rip you off. Except, it seems, for the Tories that prefer to divide the UK and insult all their allies over internal power struggles, rather than actually try and act in the country's interest.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by mrec on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:57PM (#19676754)
> it's just plain obvious how it's not in the EU's interest to keep the UK in an arrangement that it's uncomfortable with

It's very much in the EU's economic interest to keep the UK as a captive market for their exporters. It's very much in the EU's financial interest to put the UK on the hook for any liabilities it cares to dream up. It's very much in the EU's institutional interest to inflict a humiliating defeat so as to dissuade other members from leaving. And I don't see that if the WA goes through there'd be much "uncertainty"; the UK would be screwed, no two ways about it, unless it throws Northern Ireland under the bus.

It'd be nice to imagine that broader, fluffier, more forward-thinking interests were being considered as well, but I haven't seen any sign of that so far.

I do think a lot of people in Europe and elsewhere are misinterpreting the anger in the UK at the moment. No, the EU isn't evil or malicious; it's acting perfectly rationally according to its interests as it sees them, and those interests make perfect sense in a realist view of IR. It found itself pushing on an open door with Theresa May and it'd be wholly unrealistic to expect it to stop pushing out of some weird sense of fair play. The anger is about the EU, but it's mostly not directed at the EU; it's directed at the UK political establishment.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by imtringued on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @04:38PM (#19677079)
The choice of words matters. Any type of self preservation by the EU is demonized as evil self interest.

positive wording -> negative wording

Keep 4 core principles of the single market as written in the "constitution"? -> EU is strong arming the UK and trying to punish it in negotiations and is not willing to even give small concessions.

UK is part of the EU until Brexit negotiations have been concluded -> EU has the upper hand in negotiations.

EU wants to avoid a hard border and the potential societal unrest at all costs with the backstop -> EU is trying to tie the UK into the customs union indefinitely with the backstop. / The EU is trying to impose a border between northern Ireland and the mainland.

I mean seriously what did you expect? Negotiating the constitution of a country or political union isn't realistic at all. It was never going to happen unless the other party wants to voluntarily self destruct itself. Do you think Russia could renegotiate the abolishment of human rights in the US to arrest political enemies abroad? Because that's just as silly.

Heck I've also read this gem recently (paraphrased):

Copyright directive passed with significantly more than 70% of the countries voting in favor -> The EU is threatening the sovereignty of member states by passing laws to countries that have voted against them.

The problem with the EU in this case isn't the democratic process. It's the fact that countries voted in favor of it at all.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by mrec on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @05:27PM (#19677479)
> demonized as evil self interest

I'm not sure who you're arguing with here, but I don't think it's me. The word "evil" only appears once in my comment, immediately preceded by the word "isn't".

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by cataphract on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @09:02PM (#19678749)
Doesn't the backstop apply only to Northern Ireland, though? It's even why the DUP rejects the agreement — because different rules would apply to NY.

The EU is actually not that interested in keeping the backstop indefinitely because it sees the risk that NY will be used by UK companies as a backdoor to the single market.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ben_w on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @08:30AM (#19681920)
IIUC, May insisted the backstop would be UK-wide, but not everyone seems to agree with that claim, including at least one DUP MP who thinks (or thought) it’s NI-only.

Simultaneously, many people seem to have a problem with it being UK-wide, and would be absolutely fine with it being NI-only.

Other people have a problem with both options, and yet seem to think it’s incapable of being a problem because everyone agrees a hard border would be a problem.

I really hope I’m accidentally straw-manning that last group, it would be really bad if my perception is correct.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by rezeroed on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:41PM (#19675138)
"it could last indefinitely if no such agreement is ever made" -- almost sounds like control is entirely in the EU's hands.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by scottie_m on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:46PM (#19675687)
It’s not about control, it’s just that they don’t have to extend anything beneficial to the UK at the EU’s expense. Basically the UK wants a divorce, and they’re pissed that they’re not getting what think they deserve. Whatever control issues exist are due to a treaty the UK freely entered into, and choices (like getting married) have predictable consequences. If you decide freely to marry me, then unilaterally decide to divorce me, you wouldn’t be shocked if the result was a compromise between what you wanted in terms of property and rights, and what I wanted right?

Of course the EU is going to push for every inch, and since they don’t even want Brexit that gives them a lot of power. That was (or should have been) obvious from the get-go.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ineedasername on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:59PM (#19675794)
Yes, it all should have been obvious. But the Brexiters campaigned for it on the promise that they would secure every benefit of EU membership without having to put up with the perceived downsides, and they did this quite vocally. So now much of the opposition to May's plan come from within her own party which does not want to be seen as having failed to deliver on promises that were never realistic to begin with.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by pergadad on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:07PM (#19676371)
Not at all. You're thinking in antagonistic terms. The EU wants the closest possible link and alliance - this is not furthered by forcing the other party in a position where they are unhappy. What the EU is concerned with is that the 27 other countries don't suffer excessively due to the UK's bad internal political process.

The EU wants legal certainty and had committed to protect the good Friday agreement. That's why there is a backstop. Talk to anyone in Ireland and they are convinced that violence will break out the moment the border is back up. That's why there is a backstop. Look at what UK politicians publicly say about how they will act - that's why it's enshrined in the withdrawal agreement - to make clear that the UK doesn't hold the rest of the EU hostage.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:43PM (#19676660)
Having a veto on whether the UK can leave is control.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ahje on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @05:05AM (#19680918)
The UK, and any other member state, is allowed to leave the EU at any time. There is, however, nothing saying that a country leaving the EU get to keep the advantages of being a member state. Thus, the previous divorce analogy was spot on.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @09:46AM (#19682481)
No-dealers don't want to keep the advantages - they want out.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ben_w on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @11:24AM (#19683379)
I have the impression that no-dealers generally believe that all EU membership benefits can be attributed to things other than the EU, or that they can force the EU to provide all important benefits post-Brexit regardless.

I mean, perhaps there’s someone who wants it so much they’re fine tearing up the residency and employment rights of 10% of the workforce while simultaneously messing up most import and export oriented businesses — tourist, service, industrial, and fishing/agriculture — and that having no further access to medical radioisotopes is a small price to pay for leaving Euratom, and who think it’s great (or at the very least ‘fine’) that the UK has already not only lost 10% of the value of the currency but also had a capital flight of approximately 20% of non-land assets…

But I think most of them hear stuff like that and say “project fear”.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Thursday April 18, 2019 @09:17AM (#19690746)
Your impression is incorrect. No-dealers do not expect EU policies when out of the EU.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ben_w on Sunday April 21, 2019 @03:11AM (#19710916)
So, are you one of the few people who thinks it’s entirely fine to seriously mess up an enormous part of the UK’s economy? You don’t think, for example, that such a concern is “just project fear, they need us more than we need them and will therefore give the UK a great deal”?
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:20PM (#19721296)
I'm one of the very many who thinks it's entirely fine insignificantly shake a small part of the UK economy for the long term advantages.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @06:07PM (#19677788)
They don't. They have a veto on whether the UK can leave on the terms that the UK wants.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @09:47AM (#19682487)
No-deal has no terms, hence no veto. The WA enables a veto.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ben_w on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @11:26AM (#19683389)
No-deal is not the terms the UK wants. If it did, it would’ve already left.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by accnumnplus1 on Thursday April 18, 2019 @09:15AM (#19690735)
By UK you mean Theresa May. No-deal is what leavers want. Remain is what remainers want.
Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by ben_w on Sunday April 21, 2019 @03:03AM (#19710893)
No, I mean the UK.

Theresa May is so tone-deaf she’s made 80-90% of voters think she’s on the opposite team to themselves, where half of the population think that means “Remainer” and half think it means “Leaver”.

Unfortunately, that 10-20% support for her deal means that literally no option has majority support.

No-deal and Remain both independently beat May’s deal in a direct competition.

If you put the question “do you want no deal?” to the population, almost all the supporters of May’d deal say “no”, but if you put the question “do you want to cancel Brexit and remain?” to the population, almost all the supporters of May’d deal say “no”.

If you make it a normal three-way referendum, I’ve seen Leavers complain that would split the vote.

If you make it a three-way vote with single-transferable-vote, you end up with a real-life version of Arrow’s impossibly Theorem, where voter preferences are non-transitive.

Re:EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 18, 2019 @11:40AM (#19691902)
I don't think that's accurate. The vote was on Leave (with the specifics completely unspecified) vs. Remain.

Within those who favor Leave, no-deal may be what the majority want. That isn't the majority of the country, though. If you said that May's deal and no deal were the only two flavors of Leave available, then I think it would come down to 48% Remain (using the figure from the previous vote), at most 35% for no-deal, and at least 17% for May's deal. Even if the exact numbers are off, there's no way that no-deal has so much support among leavers that it has more total support than remain.

Worse, of those who support something like May's deal, some would prefer remaining to a no-deal exit. So it's unclear, if the only options on the table are specifically a no-deal exit and remaining, that a no-deal exit is what the people want.

That's of the voters. In Parliament... who knows.