Re:Giles Bowkett: Summon Monsters? Open The Door? Heal? Or Die?
by sah on Wednesday May 21, 2008 @07:20PM
(#196662)
Simplifying the key observation: free votes put more power in the hands of users who vote more. Users who vote more are, in his estimation, users who waste their own time. So social news sites based on free voting tend to promote articles that are a waste of time.
Re:Giles Bowkett: Summon Monsters? Open The Door? Heal? Or Die?
by pg on Wednesday May 21, 2008 @09:08PM
(#196751)
Restricting the content seems to solve that problem. As long as you don't allow the kind of articles these people like, they won't frequent your site.
I haven't noticed significant degradation in quality since we started News.YC. In fact, it's gotten better, because when we started it was called "Startup News" and there were a lot of crappy gung-ho articles about "entrepreneurship."
Re:Giles Bowkett: Summon Monsters? Open The Door? Heal? Or Die?
by Spyckie on Wednesday May 21, 2008 @06:04PM
(#196608)
Yes, this is the gist of it.
The other aspect is that he thinks there is only 1 type of source that's ok for information consumption, which is the type that spews out brilliance. All the other sources are worthless, including the people that never say anything meaningful and the people that say something brilliant once in a lifetime.
Re:Giles Bowkett: Summon Monsters? Open The Door? Heal? Or Die?
by sah on Wednesday May 21, 2008 @07:13PM
(#196660)
I don't think that's what he was saying. He was just complaining that he needs better filtering mechanisms, so he can find the 1 in 100 posts by e.g. Cory Doctorow that he would enjoy, without having to read the other 99.
This isn't to say I agree, I'm just trying to summarize the relevant bits as best as I can.