The title is not “...and a deceptively simple image.” If it we’re, we would probably not be having this discussion.
You can apply the death by a thousand paper cut method of debate if you like but that doesn’t change the definition I also referenced.
The fact is the title doesn’t have to mean intention even if that’s the meaning you chose to read in it.
In any case, implying one thing even though it can literally mean another thing is standard clickbait fair.
Sure, it might be a bit clickbaity but this trend of “I didn’t bother to read the article so I’m going to bitch and moan about the title instead” I’ve seen on HN is way worse than the title in question.
To me, irrelevant nitpicking would be offering a secondary definition which is demonstrably not the definition the author or the majority of readers are using and which only applies under different context.
> Sure, it might be a bit clickbaity but this trend of “I didn’t bother to read the article so I’m going to bitch and moan about the title instead” I’ve seen on HN is way worse than the title in question.
The OP indicated he had read the article and was objecting because the title did not match the content. If a reader has to perform grammatical gymnastics to make a title fit, it is at best poor writing and at worst deceptive.
Cheers
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/deceptive
It’s quite common - in the UK at least - to say things like “It’s deceptively cold outside.” When the weather is cooler than it looks. Clearly we are not saying “The weather is not intentionally deceiving us.” Because that would imply sentience in something that isn’t. The same logic applies with this title as well.