News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by savoy11 on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:48AM (#1965213)
Why are people always writing these types of posts? .NET/VS.NET is one of the best programming environments ever engineered, no need to bash Microsoft on that. And what's the deal with licensing? We, as software developers and entrepreneurs, eventually want to charge money for some product/service and I personally find it much easier to do in .NET/Corporate settings - Microsoft has just managed to educate people that software costs money.

I find it much, much harder to charge money (I'm in the developer tools space) in the "FREE", open source, free is beer, as... whatever, and all that crap world, where people would just expect you to work full-time several years with $0 revenue - I just do not understand all that crap.

So massive respect to Microsoft - these guys are doing us a huge favor by educating people that software costs money.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:20AM (#1965349)
> Why are people always writing these types of posts?

Most probably because...

> .NET/VS.NET is one of the best programming environments ever engineered

... simply isn't true.

Unless you are saying it's one of the 10.000 best programming environments ever engineered or that others, like Smalltalk/80, Genera, Interlisp, Turbo Pascal, the NeXT toolset, Zope, Rails, Django were "grown" rather than engineered. I agree VS is and has consistently been the best single IDE when you are using Windows to write software that runs on Windows, but it fails miserably out of its narrow domain (however deep it is, as it accounts for a huge market share). It's much like Xcode being the best IDE for using an Apple computer to write software that runs on Apple computers. It certainly is.

Microsoft deserves some recognition, for many times they delivered what the market needed. From its very first BASIC interpreter, to Windows, to Windows for Workgroups, to the first affordable alternative to Unix on RISC boxes (NT, for those too young to remember), to Visual Basic (the only language many corporate developers ever knew) they more or less set the tone of the entire PC industry.

As for charging money for software, the market changed. It's like complaining you can no longer sell ice blocks because everybody owns a refrigerator or that you don't sell as many carriages as you once did because people prefer cars. Embrace the change, use the tools and help build them into even more impressive ones (from the list I showed in the first "real" paragraph, 4 have always either been open-source or have a direct descendant that is). You can use them for free, you can build on them and you can improve them so they better suit your needs.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by Dn_Ab on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:56AM (#1965507)
>As for charging money for software, the market changed.

I do not agree. Nothing is free, its just that costs continually get shifted else where into abstraction. If you pay money to advertise your service then you and (others) are all indirectly paying for your software (and others') so you can be able to offer your software 'free'. If you say, choose to monetize by ads.

Really there has not yet emerged an economic model that beats simple old just charge money for it in terms of ease of implementation and use, reliability and path to profitability for someone starting off.

Sell Ads, take a minuscule rent to display ads other people bought, micro-payments, licensing, charging for support (urgh!), free (crippled) version to bait to a paid version are actually all more of the same. Except that all but the last requiring a large amount of traction in activity, reputation, users or both. Something very not easy to get, requiring a much longer runway than is feasible for most.unless they wish to seek investment, which is its own can of worms.

But I do agree, this direct charging is not going to work much longer than this decade I don't think. It is going to be very interesting to see what sort of new economic models evolve to support consumption and greed. These are interesting times. I hope to be part of it.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by jules on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:08AM (#1965527)
It's going to work for B2B for a long time to come.
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by vilya on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:39AM (#1965477)
"It's much like Xcode being the best IDE for using an Apple computer to write software that runs on Apple computers. It certainly is."

Actually, so long as I'm writing C++, I greatly prefer QtCreator over XCode. It actually helps me navigate my code, whereas XCode just seems to get in the way.

I'd agree that XCode is the best IDE for writing Objective-C apps for OS X on a Mac... but only because it's in a field of one (as far as I know). In my opinion it's a truly terrible IDE.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by jules on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:04AM (#1965520)
There are definitely no 10.000 programming environments on par with .NET/VS. 10 perhaps.
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:37AM (#1965597)
In order to determine what's "on par" with .NET/VS, you have first to define your goal. If it is writing web apps for Windows servers, it's pretty good. If it's writing desktop apps for Windows using C/C++/C#/VB.net, then VS is an obvious choice.

If, however, your goal is to deliver a desktop application that runs on Windows, MacOS X and other Unixes, or an app that runs on Symbian mobile phones, VS is worst than useless.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by jules on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:15PM (#1967455)
You should not count which platforms it runs on. The claim was:

> .NET/VS.NET is one of the best programming environments ever engineered

What you're doing is when somebody claims "trains are more energy efficient than cars" then you say "but not if you run a train on a road"/"you can't run a train on a road". This is true but that was not the claim, the claim is clearly about the productivity a programmer has with the tools for developing applications for the platforms that the respective tools are targeting.

And you can build applications that run on OS X and Linux with VS.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @09:50PM (#1968302)
> And you can build applications that run on OS X and Linux with VS.

It would be every bit as pretty as driving a train over a road...

VS is a space shuttle. Very complex, very impressive and with a very limited usage. To its credit and unlike the shuttle, it can do one thing very well.

It all depends on your priorities. If all you do is write Windows software, VS is the best. If what you do is web apps that will run on Unix-like servers on platforms like J2EE, Django, Rails, Flask or anything like it, you can tweak it until it becomes barely usable. Of course, only as long as you conform yourself to running your workstation on an environment profoundly different from what the app will run on production.

Priorities matter. I wouldn't use a Formula 1 race car to launch a satellite, regardless of how much they are impressive vehicles. Compared to what it takes to launch a satellite, they are, really, quite unimpressive.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by dagw on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:29AM (#1966416)
If, however, your goal is to deliver a desktop application that runs on Windows, MacOS X and other Unixes...VS is worst than useless.

Not at all true. Setting up VS to work with Qt isn't too hard. And once you've got it set up it's a perfectly fine tool for writing cross platform Qt apps. Then to build and test you just do some clever stuff with virtual machines and you are good to go.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:42PM (#1966956)
Point taken. It's possible to coerce VS into being a cross-platform IDE, therefore it's not "worse than useless" in this case.
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by britman on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:49AM (#1965624)
not true if you're developing the desktop app in Silverlight which will run in all of those desktop environments (of course Moonlight is not an official release from MSFT)
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by encoderer on Friday December 03, 2010 @08:00AM (#1965640)
Selling software as Buggy Whips?!

Surely ye jest.

There's more startups charging consumers now than anytime I can remember. It used to be that unless your startup was retail based, it was free. Those days are gone.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:18AM (#1966364)
> Surely ye jest.

I'm serious. The market changed. You can no longer sell a C compiler, a desktop operating system or an e-mail client. You can sell a lot of stuff.

And don't call me Shirley.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by savoy11 on Friday December 03, 2010 @02:30PM (#1967134)
The unfortunate truth is that big companies can play that game - this or that is free and commoditizing software in general - they can win elsewhere. A very good example is what Google is doing with browsers and all kinds of software just to win on AdWords/Sense.

The bad news is that small companies cannot do that easily - they typically rely on a single product/service that they need to charge people for, like any traditional business out there.

Same with app stores - they are pretty much forcing 3rd party devs to give away or sell for pennies. Sure, we get this occasional story of a successful mobile product, but the truth is for each success there are tens of thousands of apps making close to nothing.

This, for me, is NOT a good trend for software startups. The whole "free" movement make it exceedingly hard to sell software nowadays.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by bluesnowmonkey on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:48PM (#1967558)
At the same time that OSS makes software unsellable, it also makes SaaS profitable. For example it's becoming really tough to sell version control software but totally feasible to sell a version control service, in both cases because of excellent OSS software.
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by mathgladiator on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:57AM (#1965228)
> I'm in the developer tools space

We are the worst market out there to sell because we all love to build different colored dog houses and paint bike sheds various shades purple.

- - -

I've loved VS.NET in the past, but it doesn't make me happy any more. Personally, I can't have fun working with it. It is impressive, but it lacks soul.

My rants on IDEs in general: http://blog.mathgladiator.com/2010/10/on-ides-refinement-of-...

http://blog.mathgladiator.com/2010/10/if-i-were-to-write-ano...

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by blub on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:05AM (#1965246)
> So massive respect to Microsoft - these guys are doing us a huge favor by educating people that software costs money.

Unlike Apple and Google which educate people that software costs 0.99$ or is free. What the heck can I charge if Id software publishes their latest game for 0.99$?

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by daviding on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:31AM (#1966421)
I certainly didn't think I was bashing Microsoft or dismissing paying for all software.

As for why people are writing these, I'm not sure - for me it was just a 'I'm writing stuff on other stacks now, here's the blog'.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by jules on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:10AM (#1965531)
Which developer tools are you building?
Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by joe_the_user on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:22AM (#1965276)
Aside from the many valid MS-specific issues, my recent take on "why I abandoned X for Y" is that programming is still an inherently hard and frustrating activity. The final results are frustrating compared to the promise of X; The problems of Ruby-on-Rails or .NET or beautiful Perl one-liners whatever don't appear tell you get to a certain scale. So the next great thing (or the retro-great-thing or whatever) can always look good compared to the big mess you've land yourself in. And .NET could well be the best engineered system in the world for all I know but it's crazy frustrating once you get to a certain scale.

Therefore, we should abandon X and do Y, whose promises haven't yet been broken.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by recoiledsnake on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:08AM (#1966072)
>Why are people always writing these types of posts? .NET/VS.NET is one of the best programming environments ever engineered, no need to bash Microsoft on that.

People write these kinds of posts all the time. You see more of them on sites like this because people who tend to dislike and put down Microsoft and feel good about their choice constantly upvote this kind of posts.

Stackoverflow is a example of a site which shows off that C#/.NET done in a proper way is a very platform.

Re:Microsoft - Goodbye To All That... by rbanffy on Friday December 03, 2010 @09:55PM (#1968313)
> shows off that C#/.NET done in a proper way is a very platform.

I could agree C#/.NET is a very platform, if I could understand what that means.

With lots of work and a talented team like SO's you can do a lot of extraordinary things done. The fact that SO stands apart as "C#/,NET done right" shows how much work it is to build a website on that stack.

Not everybody needs to be a Facebook.