News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon speaks up about WikiLeaks decision by tptacek on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:29AM (#1965185)
Sorry. Not a Wikileaks fan. Been through the reasons why before on HN. Don't blame other people for liking Wikileaks. Have lots of friends who do. Simply don't believe it's a free speech issue with implications for everyone.

All I can say is, the vehemence of the tech crowd's response to WL is entirely predictable. It's an underdog story, tech vs. the establishment, &c &c. Amazon could have extricated themselves from this situation without putting a stake in the ground. I respect them for making a principled decision. I share the principle, but I hope I'd feel the same if I didn't. >shrug<

Re:Amazon speaks up about WikiLeaks decision by ra on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:52AM (#1965502)
For me it's not an underdog issue. Although on a purely humanistic level I can't but admire him.

Assange could have done anything with his life. Clearly he is an extraordinarily intelligent person with an ability to execute, and a belief that the general populace is being shepherded in our thinking.

I don't have a problem with that belief, nor do I have a problem with Julian putting everything on the line in an attempt to demonstrate, or at very least, test his belief.

After all, the actual leak absolutely does not constitute a breach of national security. ONLY BECAUSE, if someone is prepared to deliver wikileaks the wholesale database, can you just imagine how many less scrupulous, security cleared people (remember there are 3 million of them), are profiteering from the very same data?