News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tablets by natep on Thursday December 02, 2010 @01:19PM (#1963057)
I think that this argument is much stronger than your original one, and in fact, one that I would make myself. Although I still don't see how it helps your firewall example, because I can't understand how circumventing a firewall can be considered "using it in a surprising way."

Actually, on rereading your original comment, I think I misunderstood that paragraph. The exact wording is still very confusing to me, but what I think you were trying to say is that edw519's implicit argument (for all X, X should be open because it can be used in surprising ways) can be applied to network connections, where network connections are the X. I thought you meant that firewalls were the X, and that idea is what I was arguing against.

Re:Tablets by jodrellblank on Thursday December 02, 2010 @04:09PM (#1963656)
Your second paragraph sounds right for what I was trying to say.