News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by PaulHoule on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:02PM (#19625999)
This is also something I hear people talk about and never use.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by ellius on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:07PM (#19626050)
Very few people have the discipline to do proper postmortems, and even fewer industries and companies have the discipline to enable those people to do them.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by nradov on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:16PM (#19626131)
I have actually used it for root cause analysis of serious software defects, and that led to some valuable process and training improvements.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by robluxus on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:06PM (#19626040)
Do you have other examples? FWIW I find 5-why's useful for personal introspection, but never found it very efficient in professional settings.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by ken on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @01:54PM (#19627137)
I find it tremendously helpful with software -- but I also always include the user as a component of the system (e.g., in architecture diagrams), which apparently isn't very common.

So rather than something technical like "process crashed", most of my investigations begin with "user is frustrated because they did not accomplish their task". Then my why-tree will have branches for, say, "the label on this control was unclear", "there was no documentation for this feature", "it was not clear how to get to the correct documentation page", "user was afraid to click it -> because there was no Undo", "user didn't know this feature already exists", etc.

Usually, I have to go a few questions deep before I get to a geeky technical solution that can be solved by more programming. I'll typically come up with 4 to 6 actionable improvements, and half will be completely non-technical, and most of the rest will be less than one line of code (e.g., to rearrange or clarify).

Users don't like going to the effort of filing bug reports, so whenever someone does, it's a good indicator to me that 10 or 100 other people also failed at a similar task with my software, or will soon. Users are also resourceful, and will try 2 or 3 ways to solve something, so if they ultimately fail, it means the software failed at every path they tried. By attacking every problem at multiple levels, it's possible to improve results for a whole lot of people at once.

Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by lucisferre on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:30PM (#19626298)
We use it often, it can be very effective but it isn't the only tool we have.
Re:The Problem with ‘5 Whys’ (2016) by brownkonas on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @01:56PM (#19627168)
I have used it to success, but you have to allow for multiple answers to be given at each level that create their own branches of a tree. Which is effectively what the author illustrates as completely different outcomes. The group should make an effort to give multiple reasons in each iteration and follow them each separately.

5 Whys's also needs to be preceded by a detailed representation of what happened and followed by multiple next actions that are tracked to completion.