News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Companies Scanning Open Source Commit Logs And Patent... by brlewis on Thursday December 02, 2010 @09:42AM (#1962241)
This is particularly troubling in the US, where the company could file for a patent after seeing the commit, but claim to have "invented" the idea before. IANAL, but I think the burden of proof would be on anyone who challenged the patent.
Re:Are Companies Scanning Open Source Commit Logs And Patent... by mcherm on Thursday December 02, 2010 @10:17AM (#1962344)
If the patent is granted, then any litigant bears the burden of proof in disproving it. The cost of patent litigation is sufficient that any institution would have difficulty pursuing such a case to that point, much less a group of volunteers that maintain an open source project.
Re:Are Companies Scanning Open Source Commit Logs And Patent... by kristiandupont on Thursday December 02, 2010 @09:47AM (#1962254)
I was going to argue why I think you are wrong but I am also not a lawer so instead, I will point out that IANAL comments in legal threads generally provide more noise than signal. Maybe we should strive to avoid them?
Re:Are Companies Scanning Open Source Commit Logs And Patent... by brlewis on Thursday December 02, 2010 @10:14AM (#1962331)
A reply from a lawyer would be ideal, but since the rest of us are affected by the legal system, I do think some attempts to understand it are worthwhile.

Here's a link to argue against me, but does it apply after the patent is granted, or only before? There's presumption of validity after. http://patents101.com/2009/03/date-of-invention-first-to-inv...

Re:Are Companies Scanning Open Source Commit Logs And Patent... by stonemetal on Thursday December 02, 2010 @10:14AM (#1962332)
What are your arguments? He is right the US is first to invent. I think he is wrong in the claim to have invented it earlier bit is easy, the repo commit time line(and mailing list emails etc.) would give a firm date which the claiming party would have to have proof of inventing before. That is to say it isn't like a criminal case where only one side has to prove anything both parties have to prove invention dates.