I subscribe to some limited belief that prices rise (where possible) to meet demand. See San Francisco housing prices, or Madison, WI housing prices as companies attract and pay their employees quite a lot. So, just paying people a "living wage" isn't enough. If that's a route we go in (and I sincerely hope we don't) we need to handle every aspect of living; housing, food, medicine, etc. Just dolling out dollars/euros isn't enough.
> or do we as a society expect to try to get as close to a fair and living wage as possible for everyone no matter how much value they add
Paying regardless of performance will destroy productivity. People tend to do a "gradient descent" algorithm in work, finding some local minima of effort for their pay. I understand not all people are like this. I'm only saying I think that enough people do, that paying some fixed minimum for all no-matter-the-value will destroy economic growth.
This is mostly true in cases with artificially limited supply. You mention real estate, which is a good example in cities where (1) large employers are moving in, (2) zoning is constrained, and optionally (3) extra land is difficult to get, either because of geography or sprawl.
Most goods are not like this. Food, for example, does not typically have permanently higher prices after an increase in demand, because the supply curve will also change (additional supply is provided).
Same with televisions, cars, refrigerators, computers, household consumables, etc.
Therefore, I don't think it makes sense to throw out the baby with the bathwater: yes, real estate is not a normal market for a variety of reasons, but that doesn't mean that spreading dollars around doesn't work for everything else.
Real estate may need some special solutions, such as relaxing zoning laws, housing subsidies, evaluating code impact on construction costs, mass transit investment to increase travel efficiency, property tax on vacant properties, etc.
What do we do with all the people who's jobs are automated out of existence? Do we prevent the automation from happening, or do we just pay people for doing nothing? That's the question I'm positing.
Even with the explosion of software related businesses, the actual growth of new small businesses has been grinding to a halt [0]. I'd argue that this is specifically a regulation and paperwork issue from local all the way up to Federal levels.
If we want to "create jobs" for people who are displaced, we need to allow for new jobs to be created. The government can't "create" jobs, no matter how much money it has or taxes it levies. Unless everyone works for the government. Then we're on our way to some kind of bureaucratic totalitarianism.
[0] "Firm Size" - https://www.bls.gov/bdm/entrepreneurship/entrepreneurship.ht...
Broadly I'd also agree with you, the regulatory environment makes running any sort of business needlessly complex and difficult, and tends to increases the capital requirements greatly - though I'd argue that state and local regulations are the primary burdens at this point.
This will be exceedingly difficult in the U.S. where there is this deeply ingrained cultural belief that a living is something that must be “earned”. Basic Income and other safety nets that let people survive without working for it would be politically difficult. We are more likely to have government pay 1/2 the people to dig holes and the other 1/2 to fill them in, than have something like Basic Income here.
There is a reality that no one wants to admit - for some sizable percentage of the population, a 'job easily replaced by automation' is the best they can hope for in life - they're either not smart enough, not driven enough, or have some other issue preventing them from being a rocket scientist - beyond that, there is a limited societal need for highly educated workers - but we have lots of jobs that need just need doing, and are every bit as important, both for societal cohesion and for the fact that they need done - we need to pay those people a fair and living wage.
It comes down to a question - are we as a society willing to pay people to not work - not just starvation - but pay them a fair and reasonable wage for doing nothing - or do we as a society expect to try to get as close to a fair and living wage as possible for everyone no matter how much value they add - provided they are doing some sort of reasonable amount of work - this is the real question posited by automation.